Jacob Gerber Subscribe

Photo by Cristi Caval on Unsplash

The study notes, commentary and other resources for this passage are on 1 Corinthians 10:1–11:1: Do All to the Glory of God.

1 Corinthians 10:23–30

“All things are lawful,” but not all things are helpful. “All things are lawful,” but not all things build up. Let no one seek his own good, but the good of his neighbor. Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience. For “the earth is the Lord’s, and the fullness thereof.” If one of the unbelievers invites you to dinner and you are disposed to go, eat whatever is set before you without raising any question on the ground of conscience. But if someone says to you, “This has been offered in sacrifice,” then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who informed you, and for the sake of conscience—I do not mean your conscience, but his. For why should my liberty be determined by someone else’s conscience? If I partake with thankfulness, why am I denounced because of that for which I give thanks?

Listen to the sermon

Harvest Community Church · preached March 15, 2020

True Christian liberty is love.

  1. Liberty from Lovelessness (1 Corinthians 10:23–24)
  2. Liberty from the Law (1 Corinthians 10:25–26)
  3. Liberty from Liberty Itself (1 Corinthians 10:27–30)

In America, we are accustomed to a pretty high level of liberty. We go where we want, we work where we want, we socialize whenever and wherever we want, we usually worship where we want, and in general we're able to do what we want without really any restrictions. Now, that's a very good thing. Liberty is a precious thing. It is a wonderful thing that we have so much liberty in our society. But on occasion, even among a people who know and cherish liberty so much, we recognize that sometimes our liberties must be curtailed. They must be restricted a little bit, for our good and for the good of others.

Think, for example, about when you go to work. When you go to work, you recognize that your liberty has to be curtailed. You can't spend your time however you please. You have to spend your time in a way that would be pleasing to your employer. Or think about new parents. New parents haven't necessarily had to care regularly for a child; they've been able to largely do what they please. I remember when we were new parents: suddenly there was another little human in the house, and we had to care for this little girl, and it was a curtailment, a restriction of our liberty, that we were glad to accept for the sake of our child.

And right now we are also facing a global pandemic, where a virus is quickly spreading through all the world and killing thousands. In the United States, we recognize that this is going to require us, in some ways, to accept that we're not going to be able to socialize however we want. Now, as Americans, we love our liberty, and it's not something that we have a whole lot of practice at. But what's important to us now, as we think about this restriction, this voluntary restriction of our liberty, is that freedom in Christ is not an end in itself. It's not the ultimate thing that we are striving for in life; rather, our freedom is a means to an end. Freedom is not an end in itself, but something different.

Liberty from Lovelessness (1 Corinthians 10:23–24)

First, we see liberty from lovelessness. […] Liberty even from liberty itself. So, liberty from lovelessness, liberty for the things that are helpful. "All things are lawful, but not all things build up." We always have to recognize that this isn't an absolute statement. Now, Paul had already […]: is this helpful? Is this beneficial? Is this excellent? Whether it's helpful, expedient, profitable. The second criterion: am I really in control here? Am I really free here, or has something else brought me back into bondage?

In our passage for today, in 1 Corinthians 10:23, Paul gives us the commandment to build one another up. The question is not even just about me, but about the whole church. Will this, eating food sacrificed to idols, build us up? This question of building one another up was real. Knowledge puffs up. If you just pursue this knowledge for its own sake, it's going to puff you up. What Paul is reminding us here is that the first thing that we have been freed from in the gospel is championing liberty. Liberty is so important here.

Consider God himself. We confess that God is the one who is most free. In the Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 2, paragraph 1, that's what we say: that God is "most free." That is, out of everyone and everything that exists, we have some freedom, we have partial freedom, but God is the one who is most free. There are no restrictions on his absolute, perfect freedom. Here is what the Scriptures say. Psalm 115:3: "Our God is in the heavens; he does all that he pleases." Psalm 135:6: "Whatever the LORD pleases, he does, in heaven and on earth, in the seas and all deeps." Isaiah 14:24: "The LORD of hosts has sworn: As I have planned, so shall it be, and as I have purposed, so shall it stand."

And yet we are also told that even though the Son of God, God himself, God in the person of the Son, existed in the form of God, even though he had the full, perfect, absolute freedom of God himself, nevertheless he did not consider his rights and privileges as God a thing to be grasped, a thing to be insisted upon, a thing to be demanded at all costs. For God, liberty was not the absolute goal. Rather, we read that he emptied himself by taking the form of a servant. We read that he used his liberty for the sake of love. Christ did not do this because he was under compulsion, but because he was truly at liberty. Because true Christian liberty is love.

God used his own liberty for the sake of love, and that's the heart of the gospel: that God used that liberty for love, and then he calls us in response to trust in Christ, to love Christ, and then to live lives that are conformed to that image. Paul tells us in Philippians 2:5 that we are to have this mind in us, which was also in Christ Jesus. Our greatest problem, then, is not the external constraints around us that keep us from doing everything that we want to do at every moment of our lives. Our greatest problem is that we have twisted that liberty into a license for selfishness, a license for lovelessness. But the gospel announces that we have been freed through Christ Jesus from the tyranny, from the bondage, from the curse of lovelessness. We have liberty from lovelessness.

True Christian liberty, therefore, doesn't cling to our rights, defending anything and everything that we would ever want to do in the name of liberty. Rather, true Christian liberty seeks to make use of our freedoms for the sake of loving and serving one another. Paul gets at this in another way in Galatians 5:13–14. He says, "For you were called to freedom, brothers; only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another. For the whole law is fulfilled in one word: You shall love your neighbor as yourself."

Liberty from the Law (1 Corinthians 10:25–26)

Well, what then is the point of Christian liberty? Why even talk about liberty at all? If we're just going to say that the point of liberty is to get to love, well then, why are we even talking about liberty? Why is that really so important in the Christian life? Well, what Paul tells us is that liberty is not just what's behind the gospel, what permitted God to show his great love for us in willingly restricting the exercise of his freedom for the purpose of pursuing us in love. Liberty isn't just behind the gospel. Liberty is the gospel. And that's the second point Paul brings us to: that we have been given liberty in the gospel from the law. Liberty from the law. This brings us to verses 25 through 26.

But before we look at what Paul is saying here, it's important to understand the background. If you search the Scriptures on the subject of liberty, you will discover that the gospel declares this great liberty that we have in Christ. The gospel is freedom. The Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 20, paragraph 1, lists all the places where the Scripture talks about our liberty, and it's really a remarkable list. We've been given freedom from the curse and condemnation of God's wrath against our sin. We've been given freedom from our slavery, our bondage, to sin, death, and the devil. We've been given freedom from the sting of death, from the victory of the grave, and from everlasting condemnation. We've been given freedom to have free access to God, not from slavish fear, but as children relating to our Father in heaven.

We have great freedoms, and all believers throughout history have shared these freedoms, not only now in the New Testament, but even in the Old Testament. But New Testament believers have greater freedom than Old Testament believers enjoyed. Old Testament believers enjoyed all of those other freedoms, but New Testament believers have new freedoms that Christ has secured for us through his once-for-all intercession for us. We've been given through Christ greater access to the throne of grace. The throne of grace, the ark of the covenant, was hidden behind veils and curtains in the tabernacle, where only one person, once a year, was allowed to go: the high priest. We, though, are all called to draw near to the throne of grace through Christ. We've been given fuller interactions with the Spirit of God. The Spirit of God under the old covenant was poured out only on prophets, priests, and kings, the anointed offices, whereas we have all had the Holy Spirit poured out upon us from the day of Pentecost onward.

And the other thing that we've been given is freedom from the burdens of what in the Old Testament is considered to be the ceremonial law. Because of Christ's one sacrifice, we have freedom from endless sacrifices. Because of Christ's purity that he's purchased for us by his blood, we are freed from ritual uncleannesses, and we are freed from the ritual cleansings that they had to go through. We have just one cleansing, through Christ, symbolized and sealed to us in our baptism. We have freedom from the burden of the ongoing calendar of Old Testament festivals, so that we can worship the Lord in purity and holiness once every week on the Lord's Day. We've been given freedom from circumcision. And, which is what Paul has in mind here, we have been given freedom from the food laws.

Paul writes in verse 25, "Eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience." Understand, that's a remarkable thing to say in light of how Old Testament believers had to restrict their freedoms about what to eat. Old Testament believers were under a burden, the burden of a ceremonial law, where they had to make sure that whatever they ate, at every point of its preparation, was absolutely clean. They had to ask, is this food by itself considered to be unclean? They couldn't eat pork at any point in time, because pigs were considered to be unclean, for example. Or did this food ever come into contact at any time with a forbidden food? Or has this been mixed together? To mix meat and dairy: you can't do this, that kind of a thing. Did the butcher completely drain the blood in its preparation? That was required. Or was this food ever tainted by becoming a sacrifice to an unclean idol?

Pastor Andrew has been preaching through the book of Daniel, and early on in the book of Daniel, Daniel has to make a choice about whether he is going to eat from the king's table. It's not entirely clear exactly what he is concerned about, except that we know that he had a general concern that his food had to be kosher. Jews to this day follow kosher laws. His food had to be ceremonially clean, and if he was eating the food from the king's table, it's likely that much of that food would be tainted in some respect and be ceremonially unclean. It would defile him. We New Testament believers no longer have to observe these laws. Daniel did, and he was rewarded for doing it, because he lived under the old covenant. But what Paul says here is that believers can "eat whatever is sold in the meat market without raising any question on the ground of conscience."

Now again, Paul has just been talking about a different question. If you remember the sermons that have been leading up to this, Paul has been asking what to do if you have an opportunity to eat food in the midst of a pagan sacrifice at an idol temple. And he says that to do that is actually to participate in the idolatry itself. The problem isn't the food. The problem is that you are participating in offering that food to idols. It's to fellowship with the idol, or rather with the demon represented by that idol. To do that is to violate the first and second commandments against idolatry.

But what Paul is talking about now is what happens when this food leaves the context of a pagan idol temple and pagan idol worship and goes out into the common sphere, the sphere of the world, and is simply sold in the meat market. Is it still tainted if it once was offered as a sacrifice to an idol? Paul says absolutely not, because now this has entered not the idolatrous sphere of idol worship, but the common sphere. And he says in verse 26, "For 'the earth is the Lord's, and the fullness thereof.'" He's quoting Psalm 24:1. That is, this food no longer belongs to the demonic gods; rather, this food belongs to the Lord, as all food does. But unlike Old Testament believers, who would still be unable to eat this because of kosher laws, New Testament believers are freed from the burden of the ceremonial law. Therefore they may eat this food in thankfulness to the God who created it.

But here's the next question we have to ask: if the ultimate goal was always to give us freedom, why did God ever ordain food laws for his people? Well, the reason for these food laws, and why they are held in such sharp contrast to the freedom we have in the New Testament, is that these food laws served an important purpose for a time. God ordained these food laws in the old covenant so that by these food laws God could begin to teach his people about what he was really after. By these external, outward distinctions about which foods were clean and which foods were unclean, God was teaching his people to understand not something that was external and outward, but something that is internal and spiritual. He was teaching them, by the picture given in these food laws, about the spiritual, inward holiness that God seeks from his people.

And so the whole point of the food laws is that though they could point to this reality, they were never intended to bring this reality about. No matter how strict you are about your diet, you cannot make yourself clean and holy simply by eating foods. These foods could simply point to the reality, but they could not bring it about. The whole point of the picture was to point to the person who was coming, the person who could go beyond the external and the outward, and who could actually make us clean from the inside out, spiritually: our Lord Jesus Christ. And once Jesus came into the world to inaugurate this spiritual ministry by his Holy Spirit, the picture was no longer necessary. To continue slavishly following these old food rules would be to prefer the picture over the person.

And so when Paul reminds us that we have freedom and we have liberty, he's reminding us about the heart of the gospel. No longer are we dealing with external, outward forms. We are dealing with the reality that those forms always pointed to but could never accomplish for us. These pictures pointed to the person, and now through the gospel we have been given Jesus Christ and him crucified. And through Jesus we have liberty from the law, liberty from what the law pointed to but could never accomplish for us. So for the sake of the gospel, Paul doesn't in the least want to diminish our freedom. He's saying we're free; we're far more free than even believers under the old covenant were.

Liberty from Liberty Itself (1 Corinthians 10:27–30)

But still, Paul goes on to insist that even so, freedom is not the ultimate point. Freedom was behind the bringing about of the gospel: Christ Jesus exercised his freedom for the sake of love. The gospel then gives us freedom, freedom from the law, so that we have this new liberty in Christ, where we're not under the obligations of the picture; we have the person. But freedom is not the ultimate purpose in itself. Freedom then leads us to where God is calling us. If we felt compelled to exercise our freedom slavishly in every situation we possibly could, we would not be truly free. So Paul offers one more clarification, not about the extent of our liberty (we're free, he's insisting), but about how we should exercise our liberty. And what Paul says in this third and final section is that we are so free that we have liberty from liberty itself.

And so Paul gives us a case study. He says, well, what about this, in verse 27: "If one of the unbelievers invites you to dinner and you are disposed to go"? Well, here's what you should do: "eat whatever is set before you without raising any question on the ground of conscience." Now, it's important that we recognize that Paul has sort of casually identified another new liberty that we enjoy in the New Testament, which Old Testament believers did not get to enjoy. Old Testament believers were not allowed to enter into the homes of unclean unbelievers. Think about Acts chapter 10, where God has to give Peter a vision three times to let Peter know that it's finally okay for him to enter into the home of a Gentile named Cornelius, to share the fact that Jesus Christ has expanded the gospel not just to the people of Israel, but beyond it to all the nations of the earth. The person has accomplished what the picture of clean and unclean foods, of remaining outside the homes of the unclean, could never accomplish.

And so here Paul recognizes that New Testament believers are entirely free, entirely at liberty, to enter socially into the homes of unbelievers, unless of course it's not a good idea, for the sake of not getting someone sick, under our current situation right now. But, Paul says, if you do go (you know, several months from now, when we get the all clear from the CDC), how should we be handling this? Well, Paul says in verse 28, "But if someone says to you, 'This has been offered in sacrifice,' then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who informed you, and for the sake of conscience."

Now, this is sort of a complicated passage. It's much debated. Who is doing this informing about the source of the meat that's being served, and what's their purpose here? Some people think this is the host, who's worried about the scruples of the Christian. Some people think this is an unbelieving guest who maybe is just trying to provoke the Christian, to see what the Christian will do. Others think this is a weak believer who doesn't understand his or her freedom: Should I be eating this? Can I eat this?

Well, in my judgment, I do think it is probably the weak believer that Paul has in mind: this question of the weaker believer who doesn't truly have the knowledge to understand that they are actually free to eat this food, even though at one point it was sacrificed to an idol. That's the whole context, the question that Paul has been asking since he began broaching this topic in chapter 8. In chapter 8, verses 1 through 13, he's talking about how the weak should interact with the strong and the strong with the weak. And then in chapter 9, verse 22, he talks about winning the weak. He says, "For the weak I became weak, that I might win the weak." And what that means, as Paul said in 1 Corinthians 8:13, is that if food makes my brother stumble, my weaker brother stumble, I will never eat meat, lest I make my brother stumble.

Well, here Paul is saying again: this weaker brother has a conscience issue that isn't objectively, absolutely true. In the old covenant these foods were forbidden, but in the new covenant, in Christ, these foods are no longer forbidden. Well, nevertheless, my brother is weak; he doesn't have this knowledge; he doesn't have this full freedom of conscience in the way that he perhaps could. Well, even so, I am not going to eat this meat. I'm going to refrain from eating it myself, in order to avoid making my brother stumble.

Now Paul, understand, is very clear that he is not saying that the other person's conscience, the weaker brother's conscience, restricts his freedom. Rather, what he is saying is that out of concern for this weaker brother, he is going to restrict the exercise of his freedom. He says in verse 29, "I do not mean your conscience." I don't mean you, who understand that you are at liberty to eat this. "But his": for the sake of the conscience of the weaker brother. If this were an unbeliever, it's hard to understand why Paul would be talking about the conscience of the unbeliever. Unbelievers don't have a conscience about this sort of a thing. It would only be a weaker believer. That's why I think that a weaker believer is in view. And Paul is saying, "I do not mean your conscience, but his." But then he says, "For why should my liberty be determined by someone else's conscience?" My liberty is not determined by what the weaker brother believes, but my exercise of it is. The liberty is retained unencumbered.

Verse 30: "If I partake with thankfulness, why am I denounced because of that for which I give thanks?" Paul does not feel compelled to exercise his liberty in any and every situation. He is not dominated, enslaved, by his desire for more and more liberty. He desires something better. He wants to be helpful. He wants to build the body of Christ up. He wants to pursue love.

Application

Well, so what should we do with this? Three applications, to apply this text to our lives. The first is this: seek true liberty through submission to Christ. Our culture loves liberty. We've been talking about that. But our culture defines liberty in a very particular way. When we think about liberty, we mean freedom from any outside burdens, boundaries, rules, morality, constraints, restrictions whatsoever. We want liberty in order to pursue any and every opportunity that we desire in our lives. There's a lie in all of this. We believe that we are ultimately, entirely, fully free, and yet the more we are under the compulsion to exercise our liberty in all of these cases, the more we find out that we are in fact enslaved. If you live to pursue everything you desire, you will in fact be enslaved to forces that you cannot see.

It's not enough just to remove external constraints from your life if in your heart you are in bondage to the world, the flesh, and the devil. We're not actually in control; we are blind slaves in that situation who think that we are in control. The proof of this is when we try to quit our sin entirely. Oh sure, we can manage our sin to some degree or another, but if you ever try to really quit your sin, you find that it's impossible to do. Our sin sort of floats us along, like when you've been on an inner tube in a lazy river, just sort of sitting on this inner tube, floating around this lazy river. You think that you're completely in control. You think that this is so easy, so free, that if you wanted to do something different, you could, but you're just floating. It's easy. But if you've ever gotten off the inner tube and tried to swim against the current in a lazy river, you discover that it's actually very difficult. You think that you are free. You think that you're just going along with what you want. But if you ever try to swim against the current, you find it's nearly impossible.

What we need is not just to go along with our sin, to insist upon our liberty by pursuing everything that we want in our hearts. Rather, we need real freedom: freedom from our lovelessness, freedom from our pride, freedom from the tyranny of ourselves. We need real freedom that can only come through the power of the gospel. The gospel declares that the one who is most free, God himself in the person of the Son, exercised his freedom in order to lay down his life for you. He exercised his freedom by not clinging to his rights and privileges in the form of God, but laying those down by taking the form of a slave. He freely took upon himself the limitations of human nature. He freely submitted himself under the full extent of the law. He freely submitted himself through the course of life and death. He freely did all of these things for you, submitting to the curse of death and the wrath of God in your place for your sin. In all of this, he never ceased to be free, but he exercised his freedom for the sake of love. And he calls you to submit yourself to him by faith, so that you may truly become free.

The second application point, after you consider what it means to lay down your life, to give it to Jesus, is to seek the fullness of this true liberty: to seek liberty from the burden of legalism. When we talk about legalism, we're talking about being burdened by external, outward obligations as we seek, by those external, outward obligations, to gain the internal, spiritual holiness that we can only gain through Christ. Now, legalism could mean thinking that we can earn or merit our salvation by how well we obey God's moral law, the Ten Commandments. We cannot earn anything by merit. We don't earn anything from God on that basis. Everything is by grace. The moral law is not the path by which we earn our salvation. Rather, for those who are saved, it is God's pattern for living a life that pleases him: not to merit anything, but as a rule to guide our lives. That's the purpose of the moral law, not to earn something from God, but to direct our lives. But legalism could also mean adding ceremonial obligations as requirements for Christians, rather than letting them live in their complete freedom.

At Harvest, we divide faith and practice into three tiers of belief. At the top tier is what we call our creedal tier, the most important aspects of our faith. This includes the basics: we believe in the Trinity, one God in three persons. We believe in justification by faith alone. We believe in the full divinity and humanity of Jesus Christ, the Savior of sinners. We believe that he died under God's wrath as a curse for our sin, that he was bodily raised up from the dead, and that he's returning. These are so important to us that we divide from everyone who does not fully affirm these basic creedal tenets of our faith. These are the core message of what we proclaim.

But at a lower level than creedal is what we would call our confessional, our second-tier confessional commitments. These are the tenets of faith that we believe are biblical, that we believe are important, that we are trying to live out, and yet these are issues that we also believe are not totally clear, and therefore debatable. There are other people who are fully Christians who don't necessarily agree with us on these topics. This would include infant baptism. This would include elder-governed churches, the regulative principle of worship. Our leadership is fully committed to these issues. We confess these in the Westminster Confession and Catechisms, but we agree that there are other Christians who don't fully agree with us. So we preach and teach these issues, but we don't require affirmation of these things for membership.

But then, underneath that, there's a third tier: convictional issues. This has to do with which politician you vote for. This has to do with whether you drink or smoke in moderation. These have to do with where you send your children to be educated. We may preach or teach about underlying principles here, but we refuse to bind your conscience about what precisely to do in these areas. To insist upon one particular direction is legalism. So we have to ask: do you feel full freedom of conscience to seek to follow the Lord wherever he may lead you, as you study his Word and seek to live your life faithfully to it? Or do you feel bound and constrained and constricted? Understand, the gospel announces liberty. Or have you sought to bind the consciences of others on these issues? This is a time to repent of this, as we seek to live in the freedom of the gospel together in grace.

The third application, then, is this: use your liberty for the sake of love. As much as we must never give up an inch of our Christian liberty, we must also ask ourselves how we can use our liberty for love. Are you willing to refrain from exercising your liberty for the sake of love? Are you willing to refrain from speaking in an area where you might confuse a weaker Christian, who perhaps doesn't have all the theological knowledge but is very concerned and convicted about different aspects of his faith? Are you willing to refrain from eating certain foods, from smoking or drinking in moderation, where you might lead a weaker believer back toward ungodly addictions? Is your first concern about you? Or is your first concern about how you might help and edify one another?

I also want us to think about this in the light of the coronavirus. We have been given a new set of freedoms. We may not think about it this way, but we've suddenly been given a lot more free time, as various events and meetings and travel and sports have all been cancelled. If these things have taken up a lot of your time, well, suddenly you have a lot more freedom to use your time in a certain way. And the question is, how will you use this freedom? Will you use it binge-watching Netflix? Will you use it on endless social media? Or will you use the freedoms you have under this new, self-imposed era of social distancing as an opportunity to grow in your love for Christ, to spend time in his Word, to study, to learn, to pray? Will you use this to grow in love for one another? Will you use this to focus time on your family? Will you use this to reach out to others?

Now that we are physically separated from one another, will you use this vacuum of direct social interaction to reach out to one another, to call one another, to FaceTime with one another, to use the technology, which will be such a blessing in this time, to gain access into the lives of other people, so that we don't remain distant even if we are not physically present with one another? Brothers and sisters, it is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Therefore, let us not use our freedom as an opportunity to indulge our flesh, but as an opportunity to love and to serve one another. True Christian liberty is love.