Jacob Gerber Subscribe

Photo by Cheng Shi Song on Unsplash

The study notes, commentary and other resources for this passage are on 1 Corinthians 11:2–34: Orderly Public Worship: Part 1.

1 Corinthians 11:17–22

But in the following instructions I do not commend you, because when you come together it is not for the better but for the worse. For, in the first place, when you come together as a church, I hear that there are divisions among you. And I believe it in part, for there must be factions among you in order that those who are genuine among you may be recognized. When you come together, it is not the Lord’s supper that you eat. For in eating, each one goes ahead with his own meal. One goes hungry, another gets drunk. What! Do you not have houses to eat and drink in? Or do you despise the church of God and humiliate those who have nothing? What shall I say to you? Shall I commend you in this? No, I will not.

Listen to the sermon

First Church PCA · preached March 8, 2026

Division destroys the Lord’s Supper.

  1. “When You Come Together as a Church” (1 Corinthians 11:17–19)
  2. Not the Lord’s Supper (1 Corinthians 11:20–22)

Well, this morning, as we come to worship, we are taking a brief deviation from our ordinary sermon series through the book of Acts to study this passage in 1 Corinthians. A month or so ago, at the February stated session meeting, the elders asked me to preach on a communion passage for this week. And from time to time, it's good to brush up on the fundamentals by going to a passage of Scripture that directly deals with communion. Now, since communion points us to Christ, and all the Bible is pointing us to Christ, all the Bible has something to say about communion. But again, it's good to study a particular facet to prepare our hearts for what we are about to do as we celebrate the sacrament of the Lord's Supper together.

And this morning's passage considers an aspect of the Lord's Supper that perhaps we are more likely to overlook than others. Certainly, I think, as we prepare to receive the Lord's Supper, we are very mindful of our relationship with Christ. We are very mindful of the fact that we are having communion with Christ Jesus as He is seated in heaven, which we have by the Holy Spirit whom He sends from heaven to dwell in us. But this passage focuses on the other aspect: that this is not a me-and-Jesus-only private interaction that we have in the Lord's Supper. This is the communion that we celebrate as a church, when the church comes together in worship.

Now, as a father, one of the things that I think grieves me most is when my children are not getting along. Now, selfishly, I will confess, some of this is just because I want peace and quiet in my home and harmony to break out at all times. But more than that, it is because I love each one of my children. And so when one is fighting with another, or they are both not getting along and there's fault on both sides, that's particularly grievous to me. I love them. And therefore, my greatest joy is when they are in communion and fellowship together in the Lord.

I will never forget the time when I talked to a senior saint, about a month or a couple of months before she died, when, with some tears in her eyes, she was telling me about her most bitter disappointment, that her children at that age did not get along. And it was just heartbreaking for her. And I assume that she went to the grave not seeing her children get along. And that's heartbreaking. Well, how much more does it displease our Father in heaven when we are divided?

That's what this sermon is touching on this morning. The big idea, the theme this morning that we have, is that division destroys the Lord's Supper. Division destroys the Lord's Supper. And so I'll consider this passage in two parts. First, looking at the problem, namely that the church was divided from one another, divided from one another. But then Paul really shows us the severity of this issue in the second part: despising the church of God. The real issue is that as we are divided from one another, we despise the church of God.

“When You Come Together as a Church” (1 Corinthians 11:17–19)

So let's look first, in this first section, at the problem, divided from one another, in 1 Corinthians 11:17–19. And since we are just dipping into this passage, it's good to look a little bit backwards, back to chapter 11, verse 2, where Paul started this larger section with something to commend the church about. He says in chapter 11, verse 2, "Now I commend you because you remember me in everything and maintain the traditions even as I delivered them to you." But now, as he comes to verse 17, he does not commend them in one particular area: "But in the following instructions I do not commend you, because when you come together it is not for the better but for the worse."

This word for "come together" is a word that Paul uses throughout this passage. He uses it five times here in chapter 11: in verse 17; we'll see it in the next verse, in verse 18; we'll see it again in this passage in verse 20. I'll try to highlight each time he uses it. And then, if we were considering the next passage, which deals with the institution of the Lord's Supper, we would see this word come up again in verse 33 and verse 34: five times in chapter 11. And then when Paul again takes up the subject of public worship in the church, in chapter 14, Paul uses these words again in verses 23 and 26. So, seven times in these two chapters in 1 Corinthians, when Paul is talking about public worship in the church, it describes the gathering together of the congregation. When we are gathered for worship, the gathering is not an incidental, optional add-on to what we are doing. It is fundamental to what we are doing as a church, that we gather together for worship.

Now, the last time I preached on this passage, I remember the date well. It was May 3rd, and the year was 2020. So this was at the very beginning of that season which we don't like to talk about or think about. I don't want to talk about it. It was the beginning of the COVID season. We were still in Nebraska, in a time when the governor had shut down really all public gatherings. I had a good friend who died in this season, and I had to watch his funeral over livestream. The governor then would reopen in Nebraska; this was much more lenient than here, I understand. They would reopen worship on May 4th, the very next day after this sermon went out. I say went out, because it wasn't preached live. It was preached to a video camera, recorded so that we could get something out on the Lord's Day to the people. I preached it to an empty room in the sanctuary, just me and a video camera, just the way God intended us to celebrate the gathering together of the church.

It was awful. As I'm sure it was for you. And I really don't want to talk more about it than I have to. We did the best we could. We made a lot of mistakes. We learned a lot through that. But the thing that really stood out, and it was so poignant during that time, was that as I was preaching about communion, we were not gathered together. As I was preaching about communion, we were not bodily present one with another. As I was talking about coming together as a church, we could not at that time come together as a church.

Look around at the people here. Don't take this for granted. There are places in the world, not for COVID, but for other reasons, because of persecution or maybe just isolation, where people cannot gather together as a church. Don't take this for granted. Watching on livestream is not coming together. But I do want to say that if this morning you are shut in and unable to gather with us, know that I and another elder would be happy to come to you and have some bodily presence as we would bring the Lord's Supper to you. That bodily presence is an essential part of what we are about to do with the Lord's Supper. But we will come to you if you're at an age or a stage where coming here is not possible. So unless we are providentially hindered, by health, by weather, God commands us to come together, and He promises to bless us when we come together in worship.

And that's what makes what Paul says so significant, because he says that when they come together, it should be for the better, and yet it is for the worse. In other words, what Paul is saying is, it would be better for them if they had not come together for the Lord's Supper. Now, how is this the case?

Well, in verse 18, he says, "For, in the first place," and really, this is the main thing he wants to highlight, because he never gets to a second point. There's no "in the second place." "In the first place, when you come together," here's that word again, coming together, "when you come together as a church." And here he's adding the phrase "as a church": not only coming together, but coming together as a church. "I hear that there are divisions," or schisms, "among you. And I believe it in part."

The problem is that there are these divisions. They are physically together, but spiritually, in their hearts, they are divided one from another. Their coming together should be an outward, physical manifestation of their spiritual unity. And that's what makes it such a sham, such a difficult thing, because they are together, and yet in the pews there is such division one from another.

Well, what kind of divisions? Well, sadly, these are factions, petty divisions over wealth and class. They're not dividing over convictions. Sometimes that's necessary. There are different churches because there are different convictions on things. The Baptists believe that you need to confess faith before coming to baptism. We believe from the Scriptures that infants should be baptized. It's hard to have a church when you have those differences. And so we can confess that our Baptist brothers are truly brothers and sisters in Christ, but we need to worship separately until the Lord Jesus straightens us all out. The Corinthians, however, are not dividing over these issues. They are really dividing into cliques: not convictions, but cliques.

And while this is tragic, Paul is not surprised by this, because the church will never be perfectly pure. So he says, "I believe it in part." And then he says in verse 19, "for there must be factions among you in order that those who are genuine among you may be recognized." Life in the body of Christ will always involve corruption, decay, and even division to some degree. That doesn't excuse or justify schisms, factions, divisions, or cliques in the church. But it means that we need to be ready for it. It means that we need to understand the deep danger when we all separate and divide one from another.

And this is why Paul says that there must be these factions among us. Not as an encouragement: go for it; these are necessary parts of the church. That's not what he's saying. He's acknowledging that God is sovereign even in the midst of these divisions. I've talked with some of you about this recently: one of the biggest things the Lord has taught me over the last year is that He uses pain. He uses difficulty, conflict, even division. The Lord uses all things to accomplish His purposes, and His purposes are to conform us to the image of Christ, to sanctify His church, even to sanctify individuals within the church. And this is what it means when Paul says, "in order that those who are genuine," that is, those of you who have been tested, those who have been approved, those who have walked through these divisions and come out the other side, "may be recognized." The Lord is purifying His church.

Okay, well, in this first section, let me just pause and say, so what? What do we need to consider from this first part of the passage? Well, as we prepare to approach the Lord's Table today, I think this passage presses upon us with three questions for us to consider this morning.

First, when we come to worship, whether it's for a Communion Sunday or just on a normal Sunday, do we come only to worship God? Is this a personal, private, me-and-Jesus experience, where the rest of you are just the background players in my personal drama with Christ? Or are we doing that and also recognizing that we are coming together as a church? Jesus meets with us individually throughout the week, but Jesus has appointed one day in seven for us to gather together, where Jesus wants to meet with His gathered church, as a foretaste of all eternity, when we will be gathered with the company of saints throughout all time and in all places, where we will be gathered together, worshiping God and worshiping the Lamb and the Holy Spirit for all time, together, collectively, as the body of Christ. It's Jesus with His church, not just me and Jesus.

This is why we greet one another in the name of the Lord. This is why we have a fellowship time afterwards. This is why people linger here for a long time after the services, at the after-party. And that's not an official thing. Just stay here and talk. You can join in on your own with the individuals around you. And this is why, in communion, take a moment to look around at other people in the church. Our eyes should not just be down. We should be looking around to see the faces of those with whom God has called us to worship and gather together. Baptism, which we saw last week, unites a new individual with the church. But the communion season is a time where, every time we celebrate it, we once again celebrate the means of the Lord's uniting us all to one another.

Second question: are you pursuing the unity of the whole church, or are you possibly guilty of dividing into factions or cliques? It's good to have friends. It's good to have close friends. It's natural to be closer to some than to others. But seriously consider whether the way that you hold your relationships may be divisive to those who are on the outskirts, on the outside. I want you to think about this. If you are old, do you reach out to the young? If you are young, do you reach out to the old? If you're young, I want to encourage you. Every week in the bulletin, there's someone who's shut in and unable to be with us. One of the things that the dear saints who are shut in love more than anything is when someone gives them a call or sends them a card or comes to visit them, especially young people. Some of you with Cadets went out to visit some of the shut-ins. When I talk with these dear saints, they still talk about the time when you all came and visited them. That was deeply impactful. Think about the way we might bridge that gap.

At fellowship time, do you talk with friends in a closed circle, or do you stand in the U-shape that allows someone to wander in? And if you see someone lingering there, that's just social awkwardness. Invite them to come join you. Let me ask you this. If you are Dutch, do you form bridges to those who are not? Do you show genuine interest in their family, even if you don't understand how to play the bingo of the other nationalities? Do you want to know about their lives, know about what's going on? And if you're not Dutch, like me, just hang on for your life. Learn as best you can to play the Dutch bingo. Learn about the value of Wilhelmina peppermints and how to pronounce double vowels in last names. The point of this is, let us all consider one another, and the interests of one another, as more important than our own. That's the example we're given in Christ Jesus. Are you pursuing the unity of the whole church?

Number three: are you pursuing resolution and reconciliation in conflict? This is so hard. It's painful, but it's so necessary in the life of the church. Particularly, are you avoiding gossip, recognizing it for the deadly cancer that it is within the church? If you have concerns, are you going directly to other people, according to the instructions of our Lord in Matthew 18, to work those out?

Not the Lord’s Supper (1 Corinthians 11:20–22)

These are important questions, but we might not recognize how important these things are in the life of the church, which is why, in the second section, the apostle Paul, writing by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, in this inerrant, infallible Word, shows us the severity of these things, the real nature of the problem. He says, if we are failing in these areas, we are despising the church of God.

So let's look at verse 20, in the second section, despising the church of God. For the third time in these verses, we see Paul once again use that phrase, "come together." In verse 20, he says, "When you come together," and he gives a very serious warning, "it is not the Lord's supper that you eat." Think about that. If they are divided, they do not have the Lord's Supper. Divisions destroy the Lord's Supper. They may have the bread, they may have the cup, they may have a lawfully ordained minister of the Word to administer the sacraments. But in Jesus's eyes, they do not have what they need. They don't have the Lord's Supper.

Note the irony in verse 21. There's plenty of food, and yet they don't have the Lord's Supper to eat. Verse 21: "For in eating, each one goes ahead with his own meal. One goes hungry, another gets drunk." Now, it's difficult to know exactly what's happening here. Some think that in ancient homes there was often one particular dining room, the smaller dining room, called the triclinium, and that could only seat nine people. And perhaps the upper-tier, wealthy elites would sit in that room, and the rest of the church would sit in another room, perhaps a little bit like looking ahead at the fine dining and everything that's happening in first class on a plane when you're sitting back in coach. Maybe that's what it was like.

Others think that perhaps the rich were arriving to eat early. They didn't have to work late, but the poor did. And so the poor arrived late, and after the poor arrived, there was no more food to eat. Others think this was something like a picnic rather than a potluck, which, by the way, come next week for an opportunity for fellowship, to bind together as a church, as a direct application of what we're reading here. But perhaps this was a picnic and not a potluck. Everyone brought their own food, so that the rich had plenty, but the poor had none.

Well, the details are obscure about what's happening here. The doctrine is very clear: when we make divisions in the body of Christ, those divisions destroy the Lord's Supper. We may have all the right elements, all the right forms. We may have the elders dressed in suits, walking through the aisles with military precision. But if there are divisions, we don't have the Lord's Supper. That's why it's so important for us to take this warning seriously.

But particularly in verse 22, Paul says exactly what's happening. He says, "What! Do you not have houses to eat and drink in? Or do you despise the church of God and humiliate those who have nothing? What shall I say to you? Shall I commend you in this? No, I will not." This phrase, "church of God," is used a number of times in the New Testament. It always communicates something of the preciousness of the church. One of the particular places where this is clear is Acts 20:28, where Paul was speaking to the elders of Ephesus, and he's commending them before he goes on to Jerusalem to suffer, and eventually to go to Rome, where he will be executed. And he says to those elders there, "Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God, which he obtained with his own blood." God incarnate, in the person of Jesus Christ, bought the church of God with His own blood, and we should not despise this church.

Application

Well, what are we to do with this, especially as we round the corner to come to this table and to celebrate the Lord's Supper? The sacrament that we are to receive is truly special. It is significant. It is noteworthy, not only because of the union that we enjoy with Christ as we eat the bread and drink the cup, but because of the unity that we enjoy with one another, especially as we eat the bread. The cup is given as a symbol of the blood of Christ that is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins. That's our relationship with Jesus. But we eat the bread first, and the bread is a particular reminder of the communion that we have with one another. As Paul wrote in the previous chapter, in 1 Corinthians 10:16–17, "The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread."

It is so deeply displeasing to our heavenly Father when His children are divided from one another. This time of communion, then, is a time for renewing relationships that have been neglected, that have gone stale, or perhaps that have turned sour for one reason or another. This morning, we are confronted by God's warning: division destroys the Lord's Supper.

I want to peek ahead at what's coming in the service and show you how what we are about to do is going to reinforce this point. Soon we are going to confess our faith together in the words of the Apostles' Creed, and when we do that, we are going to confess our faith in one holy catholic church, and we are also going to confess our faith in the communion of saints. I believe in these things. We are going to read responsively that we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one loaf, quoting 1 Corinthians chapter 10. We are going to pray together the Lord's Prayer, asking God to forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors. And in the communion hymn, we are going to sing and lament the ways the church is by schisms rent asunder and by heresies distressed. This is important.

So, number one, I want to ask, from whom are you divided this morning? Where is your fault in that? Where is unconfessed, unrepentant sin? What do you need to do this morning to make that right? And what needs to change as you move forward in that relationship?

Number two: if God's Word is confronting you this morning, making you want to withdraw from this, making you want to hide from Him in shame from something that the Word of God has kicked up in the dust of your heart, I want to say, take heart. Be encouraged. The gospel that we remember in this sacrament is that Jesus' body was given for you, that Jesus' blood was poured out for you. The gospel that we hear with our ears is portrayed at this meal. It's exactly what you need right now. You need to hear again that the cup is the new covenant in Christ's blood, poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins, and that we participate in the blood of Christ not by what we eat and what we drink with our mouths and our tongues and what passes into our stomachs, but as we feed on Christ by faith.

So, number three, I want to ask you specifically, if you're realizing this morning that you have never truly come to know Christ by faith, that you have never known the forgiveness that is extended to sinners through Christ's blood and righteousness: have you turned to Christ this morning? Have you turned from your sin and turned to Him in faith for your salvation? If never before, the time when we are gazing upon these elements is a time for you to embrace Jesus Christ by faith, possibly for the first time. In a moment, we'll say that if you do not yet know Christ, it's not a time to come to the Table, but it is a time for you to respond to Christ in faith. Well, with all of these things in mind, let us now pray as we prepare ourselves to receive the mystery of Christ's body and His blood held out in the sacrament of the Lord's Supper.


Also preached at Harvest Community Church, May 3, 2020