Jacob Gerber Subscribe

Photo by Mick Haupt on Unsplash

The study notes, commentary and other resources for this passage are on 1 Corinthians 15:1–58: The Resurrection.

1 Corinthians 15:1–8

Now I would remind you, brothers, of the gospel I preached to you, which you received, in which you stand, and by which you are being saved, if you hold fast to the word I preached to you—unless you believed in vain. For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep. Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles. Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.

Listen to the sermon

Harvest Community Church · preached April 21, 2019

In the gospel, God weaves together the stark facts of history into the greatest story ever told.

  1. The Gospel Story Is Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:1–2)
  2. The Stark Fact of Christ’s Death Was Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:3–4a)
  3. The Stark Fact of Christ’s Resurrection Was Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:4b–8)

This past week, my wife and I were watching a television show, and it was the finale—not the season finale, but the series finale. In this show, as we watched it, we had to say goodbye to characters to whom, to some degree, we had formed emotional attachments. We had known them. We had seen their story unfold. And we got to the end of this episode, and it was a hard, bittersweet kind of a thing. At some point in the episode, there was actually sort of a flash-forward in time, where we saw these characters that we had grown to love at some point in the future, doing something that they had characteristically done throughout the seasons of the show that we had watched; they were doing that with their children after them. And so you got this sort of sense that their story would continue, even if you didn’t get to watch more stories of the series of their lives.

And I’ve got to admit that when I was watching that, there was a feeling in me that I can only describe as some kind of claustrophobia, some sense that I was being sort of crushed in upon—not spatially, but in sort of a time kind of a sense. These people that I had known—all of a sudden, I had seen a flash-forward of their lives and realized that I had missed much and would have to miss much of their story going forward. And then, of course, I stepped back and realized, you idiot, this is all made up. Why are you so emotionally attached to people who don’t exist, to a story that isn’t real, to lines that have been scripted and portrayed by actors who have entirely different lives that are not real like what you have been seeing?

Have you ever felt that? Have you ever felt sad at the end of reading a novel or a series of novels, or you get to the end of a series of movies and you wonder, well, now what’s going to happen? Maybe, though, you’re on the other side of the spectrum. You don’t so much like fiction, because you think it to be a waste of your time. It’s not real. It’s not true. Things are portrayed by actors or written by authors. Why would you want to spend your time on that? Instead, let’s focus on what’s real, what’s true, what’s factual. Let’s give ourselves to what is true in this world.

And there are, of course, some scientists or historians who restrict themselves only to the material evidence for what is in this world. And what’s remarkable is that they face the exact same dilemma from a different angle: at the end of the day, if you are committed to only what is in this world, and you have no appreciation for what’s beyond this world, then no matter how beautiful a sunset is, you’re left knowing that it’s just an optical illusion of how light hits the atmosphere at a specific time of day based on the rotation of the earth. No matter how much you may appreciate a relationship, you will have to reduce it to just chemicals in your mind, in your brain, and in your body. And at the end of the day, if what you have is restricted only to what may be concretely proven in this world, then you will have to say goodbye to this world when you go to your death. Not just having to say goodbye to characters on a TV show—you will have to give up everything, if this world is all that you have.

Either way, fact or fiction, you’re left with not much of a hope. What the gospel, though, offers us is an opportunity to reject the difference between fact and—well, let’s not call it fiction, because the gospel is fact, but it has what’s the best of fiction, the reason we like fiction: that is, the story element, the meaning element. When you read a novel, or when you watch a television show or something, the reason you’re drawn to that is because there’s a story, there’s meaning, there’s purpose; it’s going somewhere. And what the gospel declares is that the facts, the brute, cold, hard reality of the facts of human history, are not meaningless. They’re not just sort of randomly shaken up and tossed into existence. In fact, they have a story behind them that is architected by the greatest being ever to write a story: God himself.

Our big idea today is this: that in the gospel, God weaves together the stark facts of history into the greatest story ever told. In the gospel, God weaves together the stark facts of history into the greatest story ever told. We have both stark facts and story in the gospel, because God is the one who is weaving together history into something that has good news for his people.

We’re going to see this in three ways this morning. Number one, we are going to see that the gospel story is not in vain. The gospel story is not in vain. Number two, that the stark fact of Christ’s death was not in vain. The stark fact of Christ’s death was not in vain. And number three—and this is what we’re here to gather about this morning, as we talk about Easter, right?—the stark fact of Christ’s resurrection was not in vain. The stark fact of Christ’s resurrection was not in vain.

The Gospel Story Is Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:1–2)

So let’s start with point number one: the gospel story is not in vain. And let’s look at the first two verses of this passage, 1 Corinthians 15, verses 1 and 2. Paul writes, “Now I would remind you, brothers, of the gospel I preached to you.” Stop right there for a moment. The word that we have translated here is preached. It does mean preached, but that translation obscures the fact that this is essentially the same word as gospel, just put in verbal form. Well, we might translate this to get it a little bit more literally, but maybe not in a way that we would say very often: Now I would remind you, brothers, of the gospel I gospelled to you. The gospel I gospelled to you. What Paul is saying is, the gospel is something really, really important. I want to remind you about it. I gospelled this gospel to you.

Okay, well, what does gospel mean? Well, gospel is a compound word. If you broke the two components apart, you would have, on the one hand, good, and on the other hand, news. That second component, the word news, does show up on its own, without the prefix good involved, and it shows up to talk about news: facts, data, information, history. Sometimes this news is good, sometimes it’s bad, sometimes it’s indifferent, but it’s the kind of news that you might pick up in the newspaper or on the nightly news. It’s news.

But the difference between general news and this news that Paul is talking about is that this is good news. It’s not just stark historical fact. It is good in the sense that this news actually works its way out in some sense that is good for you. It’s good news for you. This news is not meaningless. It’s not insignificant. It is good news for you. And so Paul says, I want to remind you of this gospel that I gospelled to you. I preached this good news to you.

And then he says, this is the gospel “which you received.” You received it. You heard it. You considered it. You believed upon it. This is the gospel “in which you stand.” This gospel became the firm foundation upon which you build your life. And this is the gospel “by which you are being saved.” The good news of this news, the goodness of this news, the way that God has worked together into a story the stark facts of human history, is such that this good news actually is for your salvation. It’s that significant, that important, that big of a deal. This good news will save you, if you receive it, if you stand upon it, if you believe it.

By it you will be saved “if,” Paul says, “you hold fast to the word I preached to you”—or here again, that I gospelled to you. You’ve got to stay in this, Paul says. This isn’t just a nice little story you might tell to encourage yourself through the rest of the day. This is the kind of thing that means life or death. This means heaven or hell. This is the kind of news on which you will either build your life and be saved in eternity to come, or it is the kind of news that you will reject, and one day you will realize that you have rejected it to your eternal condemnation. This is a big deal. Hold fast to this. You’ve received it. You’ve stood upon it. Now hold fast to it. This is the good news of the gospel, Paul says.

And because of all of this, Paul says, this gospel story is not in vain. Look at how Paul closes out verse 2. He raises a concern, a question, an issue, something that we’re going to have to work through this morning. He says, “unless you believed in vain.” So there’s this story—but is it like the television show that I watched this week? Is it made up? Is it to no purpose? Is it to no avail? Is it of no significance or consequence? Well, Paul says, no. This good news, this story, is not in vain.

Now, this word in vain—Paul actually uses it in a couple of other places in his writings, and Charles Hodge points out that it kind of has two meanings. The first meaning we see in Colossians 2:18. Paul is urging the church at Colossae not to be disqualified by believing a bunch of different doctrines, he says, without reason, without cause, or maybe without evidence. Don’t believe something in vain, in the sense that you don’t have a cause or evidence or stark facts to back up why you would believe in this. In other words, if the gospel is not true, that’s what he’s saying here, then you have no reason to believe in it.

But there’s another sense in which Paul uses it, which we see in Galatians 4:11, and it’s the idea of in vain in the sense of significance. It’s either because of a lack of evidence—that would be in vain—or a lack of significance. In other words, does the gospel actually accomplish anything? In Galatians 4:11, Paul writes, I am afraid I may have labored over you in vain. It didn’t do anything. It didn’t accomplish anything.

So we have to ask two questions about the gospel that he is about to put forward in front of us. Number one, do we have evidence to believe the gospel? And number two, is the gospel of any enduring significance? These were the pressing questions that existed in the first century, when Paul was writing this letter to the Corinthians, and they’re still significant today. Do we have evidence to believe that Christ died, was buried, and rose again? And is there any significance to that fact? So let’s go on. We have this gospel story. We’re told that it’s significant, so significant that this gospel story is not in vain.

The Stark Fact of Christ’s Death Was Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:3–4a)

And now let’s move on to the facts. So the second section of our text today will look at the question of the stark fact of Christ’s death. And specifically, in verses 3 and 4a, we’re going to see that the stark fact of Christ’s death was not in vain. Now, when we consider the death of Christ, the issue isn’t so much with the evidence. Everyone believes that Christ died. It’s not really a disputed point. The friends of Jesus believed that Jesus died. The foes of Jesus believed that Jesus died. Everybody believes that Jesus died. Evidence isn’t the issue. The question is whether the death of Jesus accomplished anything, whether there was any significance to it. And so that’s what we have to read and discover.

So, verse 3. Read with me. Paul says, “For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received.” Paul is saying, I didn’t make this up. I didn’t invent this. I wasn’t the author of this. I received this, and as a faithful witness, I handed it on to you. And by implication, we who receive this directly from Paul, who received it from those who were in Christ before him, need to continue handing it on, as the church has done for the last two thousand years. Think how many Easters there have been, celebrating the resurrection of Christ, in that time.

So Paul writes in verse 3, “I delivered to you as of first importance”—critical, significant, necessary; you’ve got to know this—“what I also received.” And so he starts with the fact that Christ died. That Christ died. Now, again, the death of Christ isn’t really in question. It isn’t really debated. But Paul does give us some evidence for it, so we should consider it. Look in verse 4. He says not only did Christ die, but also “that he was buried.” The burial of Jesus is an important part of the evidence in establishing how real, how true, how deep the death of Jesus went.

In other words, this isn’t figurative. It isn’t metaphorical. It isn’t exaggerated. His disciples weren’t saying, boy, Jesus really—he had a tough time. Man, what a tough day he had. He just died. I mean, it was terrible. No, this is the kind of death where, when Jesus breathed his last, his friends had to go and ask permission to take his dead, lifeless corpse off of the cross and to carry him, lifeless. Blood wasn’t pumping. There was nothing going on in his brain activity. He was completely under the power of death, and they buried that corpse in a tomb. He was, in the words of Charles Dickens, as dead as a doornail. Absolutely dead. So dead that he was buried. That’s the evidence that Paul gives to establish the fact that he was indeed dead.

Now, again, I say that friends and foes, even to this day, believe that Jesus died on the cross. The evidence is not really in question. Consider Bart Ehrman. If you know Bart Ehrman, he’s a scholar of early Christianity. He teaches at the University of North Carolina. If you turned on the History Channel this week and tried to watch a special on Jesus or Easter or the resurrection, you probably saw an interview with Bart Ehrman, because he often shows up, because his life’s mission is to disprove Christianity as we would believe it, the Christianity of the Bible. He has lots of different ideas about what happened, because he’s a historian who rejects the authority of the Bible.

But here’s what he says. He says, I am an agnostic—that is, he doesn’t know what to believe—an agnostic with atheist leanings. In other words, if you really pushed him, he’d probably say there was no God, but he doesn’t really know. He says, and my life and views of the world would be approximately the same whether or not Jesus existed. My beliefs would vary little. The answer to the question of Jesus’s historical existence will not make me more or less happy, content, hopeful, likable, rich, famous, or immortal. Now, that’s not true. I would disagree with him on that, but let’s keep listening to him. He says, but as a historian, I think evidence matters, and the past matters. And for anyone to whom both evidence and the past matter, a dispassionate consideration of the case makes it quite plain: Jesus did exist. And then he goes on to say he’s probably not the Jesus of your religion. But then he goes on to say, but he did exist, and we can say a few things with relative certainty about him.

So what are those things? Well, he goes on later in his book—this is, by the way, Did Jesus Exist?—he goes on to say, the data shows beyond a shadow of reasonable doubt that Jesus must have existed as a Palestinian Jew who was crucified by the Romans. Now, that’s a man who has no vested interest in Christianity. That’s a man who rejects the Jesus of the Bible. But he is a historian who has carefully considered the evidence, and he says there’s no reason to disbelieve that Jesus Christ was a man who was crucified by the Romans, that Jesus died. So the evidence is there.

What about the significance, then? Is there any significance to the crucifixion of Christ? Did the death of Jesus on the cross accomplish anything? Now, this, of course, is where the real question is, right? I mean, everyone dies, and in fact, lots of people were crucified like Jesus. There was a Roman general named Crassus who crucified six thousand people, his enemies, in a single day. Six thousand of his enemies in a single day. Why do we think that the death of Jesus was more significant than the deaths of all of those six thousand people? Even on the day that Jesus was crucified, we are told that there were two other people who were crucified alongside him, one on each side, two robbers. Why was the crucifixion of Jesus more significant than those two robbers’?

Well, of course, this isn’t just about the stark facts. This is a question of whether there’s significance, whether there’s a story where God himself is weaving together those facts to have any significance. And this is what Paul tells us. He says, “I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received,” verse 3, “that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures.” Now, for our sins is the significance. We’ll come back to that in a moment.

But look first at what he says: “in accordance with the Scriptures.” Now, this has kind of two ideas here. On the one hand, this means that Christ’s death happened just as the Old Testament Scriptures—which were written hundreds and thousands of years before the life of Jesus—just as those Scriptures predicted. But then also, the Scriptures tell us not only that it would happen, but why it would happen.

If you were here with us on Good Friday, a couple of nights ago, as we listened to the Scriptures, we had an Old Testament reading from Isaiah chapter 53. This was written six hundred or seven hundred years before the life of Jesus. And here is what Isaiah the prophet writes, foretelling the death of Jesus on the cross. He writes, But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned, every one, to his own way; and the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all.

That when the Messiah would come, when the Messiah would be pierced, when he would be crushed, when he would receive upon himself a chastisement that would bring us peace, when he would receive wounds, those would not be in vain. They would have a significance, a purpose: that because Jesus was pierced, because Jesus bled, he was punished for our sins. That’s what Paul writes: that Christ died not for no purpose, but for our sins.

All world religions, or even religions that say they aren’t a religion, in some way or another offer humankind an opportunity to deal with our sins. Sin is something we feel, even if we don’t want to admit it. Sin is something we know we are guilty of, even if we wish it would go away. Sin is something that has severe consequences, even if we want to deny that it does. And so all religions, in one way or another, are trying in some way to account for sin, in some way to get rid of sin, in some way to atone for sin. Every other world religion, in one way or another, says, here is what you can do to get rid of your sins.

Christianity and Christianity alone, the gospel of Jesus Christ alone, says, no, no, your sin is so serious, so significant, so weighty, so heavy, so filthy, so vile, so polluted before a holy God that there is nothing you could ever do, either now or in eternity, to sufficiently atone for it. You can’t put away your own sins. But the gospel, the good news, is that in real, factual, flesh-and-blood human history, God himself took on a human nature, and in that human nature, by virtue of that human nature, God died for you. Christ died not for no purpose, but for your sins. When he went to the cross, he was being tortured, and he was suffering, and he was bleeding in your place, for what you have done, for your sins. He died for your sins. The good news of the gospel is that what Jesus did at the cross wasn’t in vain, that God had a purpose for it, that he was using the death of Christ to atone for your sins and your guilt and your shame and your unholiness.

The death of Christ, therefore, is critical. But again, it’s Easter. It’s Easter. That tells us that there’s a little bit more to this story, right? It is necessary, but not necessarily sufficient. It’s critical, but not quite enough to insist that Jesus died, or even that he died for our sins. No, no, that stark fact of Christ’s death is important. Christ’s death was not in vain. But there’s another fact that we have to consider.

The Stark Fact of Christ’s Resurrection Was Not in Vain (1 Corinthians 15:4b–8)

And this brings us to section number three: the stark fact of Christ’s resurrection. The resurrection was not in vain. The stark fact of Christ’s resurrection was not in vain. Now, when we deal with the resurrection of Christ, of course, the issue really isn’t the significance of Christ’s resurrection. If a dead man rose from the dead, that changes everything. If a man who is dead as a doornail, whose lifeless corpse was buried in a tomb, actually rises up and comes back to life, then everything we believe about everything must be turned on its head. No one would dispute the fact that if a man was raised from the dead, then we all must take heed and pay attention to it. It’s very significant. The question of whether believing in the resurrection is in vain is not about the significance, but it’s about the evidence. Is there cause to believe in the resurrection?

Now, this is where I want to direct your attention—we’re going to look at this in conjunction with what Paul writes—to a very good article. There’s a stack out there, and a stack on the table out there, about the historical evidence for the resurrection. Matt Perman works through what the Scriptures show in various places to give a historical account for the resurrection. This isn’t just something nice we believe. It isn’t just something inspiring that we can have to lift our spirits. We’re talking about stark facts, or we’re talking about nothing at all. And so it is a critical question to ask: is there evidence to believe that Jesus rose from the dead?

And what Matt Perman considers in his article, which we’ll look at in terms of what Paul writes here, is that there are really three truths that we have to account for. The first is that there was a tomb in which Jesus was buried that was discovered empty by a group of women on the Sunday following the crucifixion. There’s an empty tomb. Again, Paul in verse 4, when he talks about the fact that Jesus was buried—part of what that does is to establish the certainty of Jesus’s death. But if there is an empty tomb, that’s also evidence for the resurrection. Where did the body of Jesus go?

Well, the second truth is this: that Jesus’s disciples had real experiences with one whom they believed was the risen Christ. Notice, as we get to verse 4, that while Paul didn’t give much evidence for the death of Jesus—again, everyone believed in that—he does give a lot of evidence for the resurrection of Jesus. Let’s listen to what he says, verse 4: “that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas”—that’s Peter—“then to the twelve”—that’s the twelve disciples. “Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep. Then he appeared to James”—that’s James, the brother of Jesus—“then to all the apostles.” And then Paul says in verse 8, “Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.”

Now, by listing all of those people, what Paul is saying is that all of these people have actually seen him. Now, it’d be one thing if we said, this is a religion in which we ourselves might be deceived, but we don’t really know; but we think that because we believe so strongly, so should you. It’s another thing for Paul to say, these are people who are making a very clear claim to have seen the resurrected Christ. If you want to ask whether he’s real, go ask them. Go talk to them. Many of them are still alive, though some by this point have begun to die. But go ask these over five hundred eyewitnesses to the resurrected Jesus Christ.

And when Paul then, in verse 8, brings in himself, he raises a really important piece of evidence, namely, that he was a hostile witness. If there was anyone who didn’t believe that Jesus was alive, it was Paul. Paul was actually on his way to persecute and kill more Christians for what they were declaring about Jesus—who was dead, now being raised again to life—when the resurrected Christ appeared to him out of the blue, an untimely-born kind of a thing. And when Paul, who was so dead set—his name was Saul at the time—so dead set against Jesus, saw the resurrected Lord, that changed everything. A hostile witness, an opponent of Christianity, a persecutor of the church, which is what he calls himself in verse 9—suddenly that man came to faith in the resurrection of Jesus Christ.

And that brings us to the third element, the third truth, the third argument for the historical resurrection: number three, as a result of the preaching of these disciples, which had the resurrection as its center, the Christian church was established and grew. From the beginning, Christianity has been about the significance and importance and non-negotiability of the resurrection. This isn’t just a good story. This isn’t just fake. This isn’t fiction. It is true, stark historical fact that God himself has woven together into the greatest story ever told. It is true, and it is good news for us.

So then, what is the significance of the resurrection, that Christ has risen from the dead? Well, Paul states this—and we’ll come back to 1 Corinthians 15 over the course of the sermon series. We’re kind of jumping out of order. We were back in chapter 3, and then we jumped ahead to 15 because it’s Easter. We’ll work our way back to 15. But I want to give you a taste of where Paul is going, and feel free to read this on your own today.

In verse 14, Paul lays out exactly why the resurrection is so significant. He says in verse 14, and if Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain. Now, that’s a different word from what he used in verse 2. It means empty. Then our preaching is empty, and your faith is in vain, or your faith is empty. And then he says in verse 17, If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins. And then in verse 19, If in Christ we have hope in this life only, we are of all people most to be pitied.

The resurrection is everything. It’s important that Jesus died. It’s non-negotiable that Jesus died. It’s the foundation: Christ crucified, Jesus Christ who died for our sins. But if he’s still dead, if he’s still in the tomb, then we are of all people most to be pitied. We’re wasting our time. You’re wasting your breath. You’re wasting your energy being here this morning. But it’s true. It’s true. Jesus Christ is raised from the dead.

Application

So what do we do with this? Three application points to close this morning. Number one: investigate the gospel. Investigate what is declared and claimed in the good news of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Study the Scriptures. Figure out what the evidence is. Paul gives you a lot right here. Read the other accounts. Use this article as a way of studying the Scriptures a little bit more clearly. Investigate this. Again, this is the most important message you will ever make a decision about in your life, that you will ever consider, that you will ever ponder in your life. Because Paul says this is the message by which you will be saved, if you receive it in faith. And more than that, if you hold fast to the word that Paul gospelled to them. You’ve got to stay with this, Paul says, because this is the most important thing to believe. So, first of all, investigate the gospel. Study the evidence and consider the significance.

Number two: believe the gospel. The gospel message of Jesus Christ declares to you that your sins can be forgiven, that Jesus Christ, the eternal Son of the Father, has actually paid the full price of your sins, that he was slain like a sacrificial lamb, that he bled out, and that his blood is sufficient to cover the sins of all those who turn to Jesus Christ in faith. All those who look to Christ will be saved. Believe the gospel. Easter is a time when we all have to consider: do we believe this? Do we recognize its significance, recognize its importance? And so I’d ask you that. Do you believe this? Do you want this? Do you long for Jesus? Do you recognize that the good news of Christ’s death, burial, and resurrection is the only hope you have in this life and the next? Believe the gospel. Repent from your sins. Tell Jesus, even right now, that you’re sorry for what you have done, but that you recognize and believe and are clinging to the hope that his death, burial, and resurrection will be good news to save you.

The third application is this: stand firm in the gospel. Stand firm in the gospel. Again, Paul says, “Now I would remind you, brothers, of the gospel I preached to you, which you received, in which you stand, and by which you are being saved, if you hold fast to the word I preached to you—unless you believed in vain.” Well, it’s not in vain. We’ve been considering that this morning. But hold fast, is what Paul says, to the gospel.

Some of you are in very difficult places in your life, because of health concerns, because of financial concerns, because of conflict, because of anxiety or depression, because of pain in your life inflicted upon you by someone else or something else. You have a real moment this morning where you have to consider: Is this something I can build my life upon? Is this something I can trust? Is this something in which I can follow Jesus in obedience for all the days of my life? Consider what the Scriptures tell you about the significance of this good news. Build your life on it and stand firm. What happens here, what happens today, will affect all of eternity. It’s the greatest story ever told, and yet it is something that has eternal significance. Look to Jesus Christ in faith today.

Now, this chapter closes with one of the most important encouragements in the Bible: that if there is a resurrection, if Jesus has been raised up—not only has he been raised up, but we will also be raised with him. And therefore, this is where Paul closes this passage, by reminding us, Therefore, my beloved brothers, be steadfast, immovable, always abounding in the work of the Lord, knowing that in the Lord your labor is not in vain.