1 Samuel 4:12–22
A man of Benjamin ran from the battle line and came to Shiloh the same day, with his clothes torn and with dirt on his head. When he arrived, Eli was sitting on his seat by the road watching, for his heart trembled for the ark of God. And when the man came into the city and told the news, all the city cried out. When Eli heard the sound of the outcry, he said, “What is this uproar?” Then the man hurried and came and told Eli. Now Eli was ninety-eight years old and his eyes were set so that he could not see. And the man said to Eli, “I am he who has come from the battle; I fled from the battle today.” And he said, “How did it go, my son?” He who brought the news answered and said, “Israel has fled before the Philistines, and there has also been a great defeat among the people. Your two sons also, Hophni and Phinehas, are dead, and the ark of God has been captured.” As soon as he mentioned the ark of God, Eli fell over backward from his seat by the side of the gate, and his neck was broken and he died, for the man was old and heavy. He had judged Israel forty years.
Now his daughter-in-law, the wife of Phinehas, was pregnant, about to give birth. And when she heard the news that the ark of God was captured, and that her father-in-law and her husband were dead, she bowed and gave birth, for her pains came upon her. And about the time of her death the women attending her said to her, “Do not be afraid, for you have borne a son.” But she did not answer or pay attention. And she named the child Ichabod, saying, “The glory has departed from Israel!” because the ark of God had been captured and because of her father-in-law and her husband. And she said, “The glory has departed from Israel, for the ark of God has been captured.”
The Lord is jealous for his glory.
- The defeat of God’s disobedient nation
- The deposition of God’s corrupt judge
- The despair of God’s orphaned people
The word jealousy is a word that has really fallen on hard times. If you speak of someone as a jealous husband, that is never a compliment. At best, it means that this person is going to be a nuisance, but at worst, you’re talking about someone who is a danger or a threat to his wife, for whom he is jealous, and anyone who might get too close to his wife. The idea of jealousy is not a positive idea in our culture.
But when we come to the Scriptures, we find out, surprisingly, that God very openly declares that he is a jealous God. In Exodus 20:5, he says, “I the LORD your God am a jealous God.” Then in Exodus 34:14, God goes so far as to say that his name is Jealous. God says, my name is Jealous. In his jealousy, we read in Deuteronomy 4:24 that he is “a consuming fire, a jealous God.” We’re not talking about a mild sense of jealousy. We are talking about a jealousy that God himself describes as a consuming fire.
Well, if we think of jealousy as something that is so negative, and God openly declares that he is jealous, he is the jealous God, his name is Jealous, then maybe we better be clear about what we mean when we talk about jealousy. To be jealous is to be zealously protective. That word for zeal is very closely related to the word for jealousy. To be zealously protective over something that belongs to me. To be jealous is to be zealously protective over something that belongs to me. Often, however, when we use the idea of jealousy, we are talking about envy, which is to zealously desire what belongs to someone else. When God says that he is a jealous God, he is saying that he is zealously protective over what belongs to him, especially, as you’re going to see, over his glory, over his people, over his holy things.
We have to ask, how does this play out? What do we learn about God being jealous from this? What is he jealous for? What does this jealousy look like? And this is one of the stories in the Bible where we see a very clear picture of God and the outworkings of jealousy. Particularly, our big idea tonight is this: the Lord is jealous for his glory. The Lord is jealous for his glory.
We’re reading tonight a story about the aftermath of everything that happened in this battle that the Israelites lost after they foolishly brought the ark out into battle as though it were some lucky charm that were going to guarantee God’s presence and power in their battle. And so tonight, in this aftermath, we’re seeing, first of all, the defeat of God’s disobedient nation; the defeat of God’s disobedient nation. Secondly, the deposition of God’s corrupt judge; the deposition of God’s corrupt judge. And then third, the despair of God’s orphaned people; the despair of God’s orphaned people.
The Defeat of God’s Disobedient Nation
So we’ll start with the defeat of God’s disobedient nation. Now, as I’m getting started, I do want to give credit to Rick Phillips. Dr. Rick Phillips is a pastor in the PCA. He’s written a commentary in the Reformed Expository Commentary series on 1 Samuel, and I’m always drawing from lots of different places when I’m preparing to preach. But his commentary, I just thought, captured the passage so well. So I’m going to quote him explicitly sometimes, but a lot of the time he’s lying just beneath the surface. His commentary is very excellent on this passage. I want to give him credit because he’s influenced a lot of the way that I’m looking at and preaching this passage, so I want to say that up front.
But as we’re coming to this passage, again, as I said a moment ago, Israel brought this Ark of the Covenant to battle. They treated it as a lucky charm. They lost the battle. Hophni and Phinehas, the sons of Eli, were killed in battle, and then ultimately Israel’s ark was taken away from Israel. And so, in the aftermath of this battle, you have a messenger running from Aphek, where the battle was, to Shiloh to deliver this. Now, this is about a twenty-mile stretch. This is a mountainous area. And remember, this is a day before any real-time satellite imagery or any kind of telecommunications that you could instantly get updates from the front of the battle. Here you had a messenger who was the only person who was in a position to bring this message back, and he ran for twenty miles.
You may know the story. The whole reason we call a marathon, that 26.2-mile stretch, a marathon is because it was a similar kind of a messenger running from the battle, from Marathon to Athens, 26.2 miles after the Greeks defeated the Persians in 490 B.C. And this man declared the victory of the Greeks over the Persians. And after running that marathon, as anyone would do, he dropped dead after running that distance of 26.2 miles. And so that’s why we call it a marathon to this day. Well, this wasn’t quite 26.2 miles, but this is the condition the messenger is in. And he’s not coming with the joy of reporting a victory. He is coming with the sorrow of reporting a defeat.
That’s where we see that his clothes are torn and he has dirt on his head. You don’t run with your head on the ground. The reason that he has dirt on his head is because he has already been mourning as he has been on this journey, preparing to deliver the news of the great defeat of Israel and the loss of the Ark of the Covenant.
We read that when he comes, there’s someone waiting for him. Eli, priest, the judge over Israel, has been sitting on his seat by the road and watching. Now, this is so interesting, because a couple verses later, we’re going to read that Eli can’t see a thing. He’s absolutely blind. He’s ninety-eight years old. His eyes are set so that he cannot see. And yet, here he is watching. Seeing, he does not see. He’s looking, but he sees nothing. The author of 1 Samuel is starting to develop a picture of Eli’s spiritual state, and it’s not a good picture. He’s blind at the end of his life, and yet in his blindness, he’s groping out, trying to see what news might come.
We read also that he is gripped with fear, that his heart trembled for the ark of God. Again, this is telling us something about his spiritual state. The great problem of Eli was not that he didn’t know that this damage was coming. He knew that it was going to come. We read about this back in the early chapters of 1 Samuel, 1 and 2. What Eli was not willing to do was the one thing that was needful. He was not willing to repent. He knew his sin. He knew the problem. And right now, all he can do is fearfully await the deliverance of the news of destruction and judgment that he knew all along would be coming.
Well, not only is Eli blind, but we read that Eli is also deaf, at least deaf to the first report of the messenger coming into the city. The messenger comes, and in verse 13, he tells the news, and all the city cries out. But Eli, again, blind as well as deaf, cannot hear the message when it comes. Again, we have a picture of his spiritual state. Seeing, knowing exactly what was going to come, he was blind to the warnings that were given to him. Hearing those words, he was deaf to them. And we’re seeing that Eli hasn’t budged an inch since the beginning of 1 Samuel, when these warnings were delivered to him. All he can do is to say, “What is this uproar?”
Then the man, the messenger, realizes that he needs to deliver a message to the man who’s in charge. “The man hurried and came and told Eli. Now Eli was ninety-eight years old and his eyes were set so that he could not see.” Again, he’s old, his eyes are blind. Again, this is about the spiritual state of Eli.
What’s important to remember as we think about other stories in the Bible: very often leaders in God’s people become old. This happens to everyone who is granted the grace of living long enough. They become old, and very often God’s leaders, God’s great people, become blind in the course of their lives. Understand, in the Bible, some people see things more clearly once they are blind. Jacob, who lived a foolish life his entire life, finally at the end of his life, when his eyes were dim so that he could not see, in Genesis 48, we read about how he crosses over his hands to bless Ephraim above Manasseh. Why? Well, even Joseph is taken aback. Why would you do this? This isn’t the right way. And Jacob says, no, the Lord has shown me that this one is going to be preeminent over his older brother. He sees better at the end of his life when he’s lost his physical sight.
Samson, the same thing is true. Samson, with his eyesight, physical eyesight, lives a life that is entirely dedicated to whatever whim crosses his fancy at a particular moment. It’s only when his eyes are gouged out that he sees clearly the job that has been given to him as a judge in Israel, and he takes seriously the task of bringing down the temple of Dagon, the Philistines, and killing thousands of Philistines in a single moment. Some people, at the end of their lives, when they lose their physical eyesight, see more clearly. Not Eli. He was blind to the end.
And then in verse 16, we hear this report. Earlier, sort of with Eli, we were deaf to the original pronouncement. We only heard of the great uproar. We had to wait until now, in verses 16 and 17, to hear this report, although if we’ve read the first part of chapter 4, we know what’s happened. “The man said to Eli, ‘I am he who has come from the battle; I fled from the battle today.’ And he said, ‘How did it go, my son?’ He who brought the news answered and said, ‘Israel has fled before the Philistines, and there has also been a great defeat among the people. Your two sons also, Hophni and Phinehas, are dead, and the ark of God has been captured.’”
It’s a catastrophic failure. But remember, these are the last words that Eli is going to hear in his life: words of catastrophic failure. This isn’t just bad; this is the end of the road for Eli. These words are going to be what rings in his ears as he dies. And what he is hearing is that the Lord has been faithful to keep his word. The Lord has been faithful to jealously protect his own glory, even when that means turning over his chosen people, his chosen nation, to their defeat, even turning over the Ark of the Covenant to be captured by the Philistines.
You know, before my wife and I had children, we had a lot of breakable things that we just kept out. It’s amazing how many things you don’t realize are breakable and fragile or liable to be spilt until you have children who, just like magnets, are drawn to them. You cannot leave a cup of coffee anywhere for a moment if it’s in the reach of a child, because they instantly beeline over to it, trying to find what captivates so much attention of mommy and daddy in the mornings. You just can’t do anything. And so we had to go through the process of baby-proofing our house. And it became sort of second nature. It was a hardship. It was an inconvenience. And we had to remain constantly vigilant. You don’t set anything down for a moment. When guests came, we would be scooping up their things, as they’d not realize that they had put it in the line of danger. But you realize that you have to keep these things safe. Children do learn the value and the fragility of things over time, but not at first.
What God is doing here is he is sin-proofing his glory. God can no longer leave the perception among his people that things can go on as they have been going on. Again, this is right on the heels of the book of Judges, where every man did what was right in his own eyes. Israel is rife with corruption. And what God is making clear is they can’t just sort of trot his ark out as though it’s some kind of magic talisman that’s going to win the day, that they can force God into doing and protecting them in the way that they want him to do.
And so the key insight that we see in the way that God sin-proofs his glory (this is a remarkable thing to think about): God’s glory, we’re learning here, is less endangered when his ark is carried off, carried away by the barbaric Philistines, than when it dwells among his corrupted people as they persist in their hypocrisy. God is less willing to leave the Ark of the Covenant with his people when they are persisting in hypocrisy and corruption than he is to just give it away and let the ark be taken away by the barbaric, corrupt, wicked Philistines. It’s because if God’s presence is going to remain in the midst of his holy people, he will be treated as holy. We can do away with things. Things don’t matter. The Ark of the Covenant doesn’t matter. Even the building we’re standing in ultimately doesn’t matter, as beautiful as it is, as much as we treasure it. Ultimately, God’s glory will not remain among a people who will not take his glory seriously.
Well, this defeat, as the news of it reaches not only the city but also Eli and everyone else, has ongoing ramifications. The first ramification is going to be for the leadership, for Eli. We’re going to see that in the next section, and then later we’re going to see the ongoing ramifications for the status of the people who continue to live in Israel.
The Deposition of God’s Corrupt Judge
So the second point, as we come to the second section, is the deposition of God’s corrupt judge in 1 Samuel 4:18. In verse 18, we read, “As soon as he” (this is the messenger) “mentioned the ark of God.” The word here for mentioned is interesting. It’s very literally, as soon as he caused to remember the ark of God, as soon as he brought it to mind, as soon as he jogged the memory of Eli about the ark of God. The word remember here is an important word in Hebrew. It always means more than just to recall. It means to act on the basis of something that we recall. It doesn’t mean just bringing things to mind. It means acting on the basis of something that has been previously spoken, previously promised, previously pledged in some way.
The idea here is that this messenger, by calling to mind, causing to be remembered the ark of God, is evoking the curses of the covenant. Eli was a leader among the covenant people as a priest and as a judge. He had a unique position of leadership and authority. And what we are seeing here is that judgment is beginning with the household of God right at the top, with the leadership.
So in verse 18, “As soon as he mentioned” (caused to remember) “the ark of God, Eli fell over backward from his seat by the side of the gate, and his neck was broken and he died, for the man was old and heavy. He had judged Israel forty years.” This seat is fairly significant. It’s a seat by the side of the gate. If you read a lot of different stories in the Old Testament, you’ll know that the elders always judge at the gate. The gate was not just a place where people came in and out; it was the place where leadership was exercised, where justice was done. A seat here that Eli was sitting on: don’t think a public bench that anyone could sit on. The word here really talks about the kind of seat that a leader would sit on. If Eli were a king, we would simply translate this as his throne. That’s the kind of seat that is given here. He’s sitting on this seat, the last place that he is going to be exercising whatever is left of his tattered authority. And when this word comes, he falls from this place of God-appointed authority, just as God had prophesied. God had prophesied that he was going to remove Eli for his sin, and especially for not disciplining his sons.
And when he falls, he breaks his neck. One commentator points out this is exactly what happens to Dagon, the idol of Dagon, in the next chapter, in 1 Samuel 5:4, when the Ark of the Covenant is in the presence of Dagon. One morning it falls over and the hands fall off. Dagon is incapable of doing anything. The next morning it falls over and the head breaks at the neck, which means that this god has no power. To break the neck, to break apart the head: this meant the shattering of the authority, the power of Dagon, but here of Eli. And God is beginning his judgment against the leader who has played such an integral role in dishonoring his glory.
In the language of Jesus’s parable that we studied this morning, Eli’s heart was a thorny heart. He was uncommitted to the Lord. The faithfulness that he should have exercised as a leader amongst God’s people was choked out by a desire to protect his children at all costs, a desire that he did not want to discipline his children. And the problem of an uncommitted leader, a leader whose heart is choked out from faithfulness to doing all that God has commanded, is that the damage will spread. It’s not just one individual whose heart is choked out from fruitfulness. That spreads to the rest of the community.
You know, it’s sort of like this time of year, we all have to be vigilant against those devil flowers called dandelions. I absolutely loathe these things wherever they come up. My children think they’re just absolutely beautiful because they’re so bright and yellow, but I know the truth. These are devil flowers, and I know that if I do not get rid of them, that yellow goes away and they become (oh, that’s really problematic) these blowing things that my children are attracted to again, and they spread their evil, wicked seeds throughout the entire yard. You have to get rid of them before they infect everything else. That’s the kind of problem that comes from ungodly leadership. It doesn’t just affect that one corner of one person’s life; it begins to spread and infect other parts of the lawn. And again, that’s how more thorny plants, that’s how more weeds grow up to choke out the fruitfulness, again, not just of one individual but of the entire field, the entirety of God’s people.
God, though, is jealous for his glory, and when his leaders fail to protect his glory, they will be removed. The implications of the Lord’s jealousy, though, again, do go beyond this leader. Judgment begins right at the top of the household of God, but this judgment extends to the whole people. And the second response: God’s people despair over God’s abandonment.
The Despair of God’s Orphaned People
Third section is the despair of God’s orphaned people. We’re reading in this section about the orphaning of a child whose father has already died and whose mother now dies in childbirth. And what we’re seeing here in this picture of this orphan child is really a picture of the people of God. God has left them. They’re left orphaned and destitute.
So let’s look at the way the author tells this. Remember in verse 13, the whole city has heard this. All the city cried out before that word eventually got to Eli. This scene is told in a couple of different ways. It’s really trying to capture a lot all at once. Part of what is happening here is this story has been patterned after the story of Jacob’s wife, Rachel, as she gives birth to Benjamin in Genesis 35:16–19. I’m just going to read this where you can see some of what happens here. Remember, in this story, she’s crying out and her women tell her, “Do not be afraid, for you have borne a son.” And eventually she dies in childbirth after she names her child Ichabod, a very, very negative name that means no glory.
Well, here’s what Genesis 35:16–19 says. See if you can hear the similarities. “Then they” (Jacob and his family) “journeyed from Bethel. When they were still some distance from Ephrath, Rachel went into labor, and she had hard labor. And when her labor was at its hardest, the midwife said to her, ‘Do not fear, for you have another son.’” Like we read in verse 20 here, “Do not be afraid, for you have borne a son.” “And as her soul was departing (for she was dying), she called his name Ben-oni” (which means son of my affliction), “but his father called him Benjamin” (which means son of my right hand). “So Rachel died, and she was buried on the way to Ephrath (that is, Bethlehem).”
Now these stories are told very similarly, but they’re told similarly in order to bring out contrast. There are a couple of key contrasts. Rachel and Phinehas’ wife here, both of them die, but Rachel’s son brings hope. Benjamin brings hope, whereas the son born to Phinehas’ wife brings despair. Part of this despair is captured in the two names that are given. Jacob is there when Rachel names this child Ben-oni, son of my affliction, in order to rename him to a more positive name, Benjamin, son of my right hand. Not son of my affliction, but son of my right hand in the sense of, this is the offspring of my great strength. My right hand is a symbol of strength. But Phinehas, since he has already died, cannot rename this child, and this child goes through his life Ichabod: no glory.
One of the other contrasts that we see here is not only the contrast between Rachel’s birth of Benjamin and what’s happening here, but in the context of 1 Samuel, we also have to remember that this birth is very significantly contrasted against the birth of Hannah. When Hannah gives birth to Samuel, it was a moment of great joy, and there’s actually a connection between the two. It’s the unique word that appears here to describe the child, verse 21. That same word appears to describe Samuel in 1 Samuel 2:21. It’s something of a rare word to describe a child. The King James, I think, has lad for this, to kind of bring out the kind of child that this is. Again, when Hannah gave birth to Samuel, it was a great occasion of joy, but here we have a great occasion of sorrow.
All of these are together, and we have to ask, how are these two things going together? How was Samuel’s birth a day of great joy, and this day a day of great sorrow? How is God going to work his great salvation through both of these events?
When we come to verses 21 and 22, then, Bill Arnold, one commentator, points out the repetition, the repetition that focuses our attention directly on the loss of the ark. In verse 21, we hear about all of the bad things that happened: “because the ark of God had been captured and because of her father-in-law and her husband.” Then in 22, we read, “The glory has departed from Israel.” That’s the meaning of the child’s name, Ichabod. “The glory has departed from Israel, for the ark of God has been captured.” There’s nothing happy, nothing hopeful at the end of this chapter. In fact, the word for departed is not just a normal word for left, went on a journey. This is the word that’s used in the book of Kings to describe the people of Israel going off into exile. God went off; his ark went off into exile first. I’m talking about all the times that God’s people have been led off into exile. It’s a terrible, tragic way to end this passage.
Application
This morning, as we talked about the differences between the various soils, at the end of the sermon I tried to capture what’s the main difference between the good soil and all the other soils. If the other soils were all unfruitful in one way or another, what’s the main difference? And the difference, I said, comes down to a true recognition that we are sinners who justly deserve God’s displeasure, who are without hope apart from God’s sovereign mercy.
Now, in this morning’s sermon, I mentioned a number of stories of different people who in different ways fell away, either rejected Christ altogether or fell away from Christ at various points in their journey. But of course, I would be remiss if I didn’t talk about other stories of people who, when they came to the end of themselves, when the glory of God’s presence had departed from their life, came to the rock bottom of their lives, and then they came back. They were brought to the lowest point of their despair. They were left as orphaned people as God withdrew the light of his countenance and favor. There are people who have been wrecked, who have been undone because of their sin, lost because of their sin, who in the depths of their despair found just how sweet the gospel truly is. The only way to come to a real knowledge of the Lord Jesus Christ is to first come to a real knowledge of the depths of our sin, our absolute unworthiness before the Lord.
The application of this passage, then, is not as sorrowful as it might sound. It’s that in the midst of a sorrow like this, we must seek the Lord while he may be found. The Lord has withdrawn his presence here, and the Lord seems to withdraw his presence at various times, which is why Scripture exhorts us, “Seek the Lord while he may be found.” Because the Scriptures speak of the Lord’s presence as the highest joy that believers can experience. In Psalm 16, verse 11, which we sang this morning, we read, “You make known to me the path of life; in your presence there is fullness of joy; at your right hand are pleasures forevermore.” Which, if that’s true, means that the withdrawal of God’s presence is the most horrifying thing imaginable.
And so, in the book of Exodus, we have an example of this. After the golden calf, when Israel sinned horrendously, similarly to the sin that’s been going on here, at that point God threatened (he forgave them, but he threatened) to send them into the land of Canaan, and he said he would send ahead his protection, but he said that his presence would not go with them. When the people of Israel heard this, this was a disastrous word. The messenger, just like the messenger comes delivering a disastrous word here, this was a disastrous word that was given to the people, and that caused the people to mourn. God was not going to go with them. They did not want to go into the land of Canaan. And God’s presence is everything, so that his absence is the worst thing imaginable.
Another sort of scene is when Israel themselves are going into exile. One of the worst scenes in the Bible is when the glory of the Lord doesn’t just have his furniture taken away from the land, as happens here when the Ark of the Covenant is taken, but we read about how the glory of the Lord departs from the temple. The furniture is actually left behind, and God’s presence leaves, in Ezekiel 10 and 11. Understand, even heaven without God would be hell. Heaven without God’s presence would be hell by another name.
This passage is teaching us, then, three purposes for why God might withdraw his glory, especially so that God might through this lead us back to him. The first lesson we should learn from this, application-wise, is that God is jealous for his glory. He will protect his glory. Ultimately, that’s good news. We don’t want a corruptible God whose character can be besmirched, who is too weak to judge sin.
(With apologies, there was a technical issue, and the ending of the sermon was cut off.)