Jacob Gerber Subscribe

Printable study notes

PDF · for personal study or your small group

Download PDF

Introduction

On the surface, so many passages in the Book of Acts sound similar. Missionaries (now always including Paul, but others early on) come to an area. They preach the gospel in that area, and many people believe. Many others, however, resist the message and respond with varying degrees of opposition. Then, when opposition grows beyond a certain level, the missionaries move on to the next place to start the process again. Why have so many stories of the same series of events? One of the reasons is that each passage gives us a slightly different angle on that general pattern. Here, then, we hear a clear call for today: respond to the Scriptures with faith.

Discussion Questions

1. Why was it Paul’s “custom” to go to the Jewish synagogue (vv. 1–2a)? That is, why do you think Paul put such a priority on evangelizing the Jews, even though he had been appointed as an apostle to reach the Gentiles to the end of the earth? Where have we seen him do that before? What do the various words (“reasoning,” “explaining,” “proving”) for Paul’s exposition of the Scriptures all communicate about what Paul was doing in his preaching?

2. What did Paul reason/explain/prove from the Scriptures about the Christ/Messiah (v. 3)? What do the Scriptures of the Old Testament say that makes it a necessity “for the Christ to suffer and to rise from the dead” (v. 3)? How does Jesus uniquely fulfill that Scriptural picture of the Christ? What has made it so hard for Jews across the centuries to see this truth? What is different among those who are “persuaded” and believe this gospel (v. 4)?

3. What makes the Jews at Berea “more noble than those in Thessalonica” (v. 11)? How do they receive the word? With what frequency? What do they do with the message that is preached to them? How does their own Scripture study prompt them to respond to the gospel? How are you receiving the preached word? How does what you hear on a Sunday prompt you to search the Scriptures to see if those things are so?

4. What is your sensitivity to the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments? How does that sensitivity manifest itself in your day-to-day study of Scripture? Where are you careless or sloppy in your approach to God’s holy Word? Where do you fall short of putting your faith in what the Scriptures declare about Jesus the Christ: namely, that he suffered, died, was buried, and rose again from the dead?


Sermon

Listen to the sermon

First Church PCA · preached August 9, 2026

Theme: Respond to the Scriptures with faith.

Outline:

  1. Right Reasoning (Acts 17:1–9)
  2. Right Response (Acts 17:10–15)

Acts 17:1–15

Now when they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica, where there was a synagogue of the Jews. And Paul went in, as was his custom, and on three Sabbath days he reasoned with them from the Scriptures, explaining and proving that it was necessary for the Christ to suffer and to rise from the dead, and saying, “This Jesus, whom I proclaim to you, is the Christ.” And some of them were persuaded and joined Paul and Silas, as did a great many of the devout Greeks and not a few of the leading women. But the Jews were jealous, and taking some wicked men of the rabble, they formed a mob, set the city in an uproar, and attacked the house of Jason, seeking to bring them out to the crowd. And when they could not find them, they dragged Jason and some of the brothers before the city authorities, shouting, “These men who have turned the world upside down have come here also, and Jason has received them, and they are all acting against the decrees of Caesar, saying that there is another king, Jesus.” And the people and the city authorities were disturbed when they heard these things. And when they had taken money as security from Jason and the rest, they let them go.

The brothers immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea, and when they arrived they went into the Jewish synagogue. Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so. Many of them therefore believed, with not a few Greek women of high standing as well as men. But when the Jews from Thessalonica learned that the word of God was proclaimed by Paul at Berea also, they came there too, agitating and stirring up the crowds. Then the brothers immediately sent Paul off on his way to the sea, but Silas and Timothy remained there. Those who conducted Paul brought him as far as Athens, and after receiving a command for Silas and Timothy to come to him as soon as possible, they departed.

Well, in this passage of Scripture, I hope you’re noticing a pattern as we’re studying through the book of Acts. As we study through this book, we’re going to see regularly a pattern where the missionaries, here Paul and Silas, come into a particular area and they start preaching. And as they preach, the word of God is powerful in that area. And many, not all, but many, come to faith in Jesus. But as the word begins to bear fruit in that area, it’s not too long down the road before opposition begins to grow. Wherever they are, whether among Jews or Gentiles, opposition begins to grow, and very soon oppression comes against the missionaries, until things get so bad, in one way or another, that the missionaries have to shake the dust off their feet, whether we read about it or not, and they have to move on to the next area, to continue preaching the word of God in a new place.

And we read so many of these stories. There’s a real pattern forming here, but I don’t want you to think that each of these is the same story every time: oh, here’s another story where the same thing is happening. I think if you’re a believer, if you’ve followed Christ for any length of time, you probably understand that there are a lot of places in your life where it feels like you are doing the same thing. Maybe some of these are the day-in, day-out rhythms and routines of your life, day to day, week to week, month to month. Maybe you come into worship every week, and worship is going to look very similar in its format and structure week by week. Or you come across the same besetting sins, or you come across similar lessons and trials that you have to deal with and wrestle with one more time. And you say, I’ve been here before. I’ve done this before. Why can’t I move on to something else?

But what the Lord teaches us through each of these events, as we go through them, is always something a little bit new. It’s always coming back to the fundamentals of repentance from sin and faith in Christ and trust wherever he is leading us. But though it always comes down to those fundamentals, every time God is shining a different light on the reality of our situation, or the reality of our condition, or his goodness and mercy and grace and power. And each time we forget those things, even a little bit, God is once again putting them before us and asking us once again to trust in him.

I think what these stories and the patterns that we are reading here in the book of Acts are doing, in part, is showing us something of that pattern in the life of the church. If God’s vision for the church is reflected in this book, one of the things that we are seeing is that life is going to look the same, and yet in each story, Luke is shining a different light, a different angle. We are seeing a different aspect of the kingdom of God as it’s developing in this world. And so often it comes back down to fundamentals, but we catch a new glimpse. We see a new part of God’s glory. And here the glimpse we have is the necessity that the Messiah, that Jesus, who is the Christ, must suffer and rise from the dead, and the way that necessity has been communicated to us through the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments. Very basic lessons. But this passage is profound in the way that it puts both of those ideas before us.

And so our theme (and this is going to be our application, then) is this: respond to the Scriptures by faith. Respond to the Scriptures by faith. And so we’ll look at two sections in this passage. First, what we are seeing in Thessalonica, where we see right reasoning, right reasoning. And second, what happens in Berea, where we see right response, right response.

Right Reasoning (Acts 17:1–9)

So let’s start with right reasoning, in verses 1 through 9, in Thessalonica. We’re reading about the ongoing journeys, again, of these missionaries, Paul and Silas, and they “passed through Amphipolis” (or Amphipolis, however you pronounce that) “and Apollonia.” And now they come to Thessalonica. If you have read the letters to the Thessalonians, 1 and 2 Thessalonians, these are the letters to the Christians in this city. One of the interesting things, as you read the letters to the Thessalonians, is how much Paul talks about what a miracle it is that they treated the revelation of the word of God for what it was, namely, a word from God and not the mere preaching of men. And they received it eagerly in that way. And he says it’s a miracle. And he talks about the fires of opposition that they have faced. And we see that that traces to right here, where Paul is preaching this gospel and some miraculously come to believe these things, while others reject it entirely and even come to persecute the Christians, including Jason, apparently the one with whom these missionaries lodged while they were in Thessalonica.

But upon coming to Thessalonica, we read, there was “a synagogue of the Jews.” If you remember, there was not a synagogue of the Jews in Philippi. There were not enough Jewish men in that town to be able to form a synagogue. But here there are, and there’s a strong Jewish contingent. And so we read that Paul, “as was his custom,” starts his ministry in the synagogue. He went in, as was his custom, to the synagogue, “and on three Sabbath days he reasoned with them from the Scriptures.”

Now, why does Paul start his mission in the Jewish synagogue? Well, Jesus was careful to remind us in John chapter 4 that salvation is from the Jews. Jesus himself was a Jew born to Jews, fulfilling the long-awaited promises that God had made to his covenant people, the Jews, that salvation would come from one born to their ranks. But Paul also, reflecting on this in the letter he wrote to the church in Rome, the letter to the Romans, reminds us in Romans 3:2 that to the Jews were entrusted the oracles of God. They should understand something of what he is going to be preaching about, because he is appealing to the Scriptures, the oracles that they have possessed. And then in Romans 9:4–5, Paul goes on, writing, “to them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the law, the worship, and the promises. To them belong the patriarchs, and from their race, according to the flesh, is the Christ, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen.”

They should know what he is talking about. He is starting to preach to them that the long-awaited promises, the covenants that God made with his people, what was foretold and foreshadowed by the worship that was given to them, have been fulfilled in the Messiah. That is the Hebrew word. In Greek, it is translated as the Christ, which is what he is preaching about in this passage.

And so we read that he goes into the synagogue of the Jews, “and on three Sabbath days he reasoned with them from the Scriptures.” Now, this is the very first time in the book of Acts that we come across this word for reasoning. However, it actually comes up several times from here on out, particularly when Paul is reasoning with the Jews. He’s talking with the Jews in their language, from their Scriptures, according to the promises made to them about the Messiah raised up from their race according to the flesh, who is the God whom their ancestors and the patriarchs had worshiped. And he reasons with them, saying the Messiah has come.

But then it goes on to say what exactly he reasons with them about from the Scriptures. Verse 3: “explaining and proving.” The word for explaining is a word that essentially means something like opening up. In Luke chapter 24, when Jesus was resurrected and he’s talking with the men on the road to Emmaus, it says that he opened their minds to understand the Scriptures. That’s this word. And so here Paul and Silas are trying to open their eyes, open their minds, to understand what the Scriptures declared about the Messiah. And this word proving, then, is something like setting something before people. Physically, this can be something like Jesus setting the fish and loaves before the crowds when he miraculously multiplied those meals for five thousand, and then for crowds of four thousand. So, here’s Paul reasoning and explaining, trying to open their eyes; proving, setting before them the scriptural proof.

And what is he saying the Scriptures teach? As he pleads with them to believe, he points to the Scriptures, reasoning with them from the Scriptures, “that it was necessary for the Christ to suffer and to rise from the dead.” Now, this is the heart of the message. Again, it comes back to basic blocking-and-tackling fundamentals. It comes back to the heart of what we preach, the core of what we are about, namely, Jesus and him crucified. But what Paul is saying is that this is not a small part of what you should know. This is what you should be very acquainted with, because you have these Scriptures. The oracles of God were entrusted to you in the Scriptures of the Old Testament.

Now, what Paul is saying here is that the Messiah—the suffering and death and the resurrection of the Messiah—had always been proclaimed from the Scriptures. And when we study the Scriptures, a simple principle of trying to understand what the Scriptures teach is that we are to look for both precepts and examples. Precepts and examples. Precepts mean some kind of clear, explicit teaching on a matter. Examples put flesh and blood on principles. They show us stories of real-life human beings who struggle and sin in the same ways that we do, who are learning about those things as they go through life. Precept and example.

Well, did the Scriptures teach by precept that the Messiah would suffer and die? And the answer is absolutely. It’s taught in many places. Probably the clearest is in Isaiah 53:5–6. And I’m just using two verses out of that lengthy section that talks about the suffering Servant, the Messiah, where we read, “But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed. All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned—every one—to his own way; and the LORD has laid on him the iniquity of us all.” That was written seven hundred years before the hands and feet of Jesus were pierced on the cross.

But what about example? One of the best books that I’ve read (I wouldn’t say it’s my favorite) is a book by Arnold Fruchtenbaum called Jesus Was a Jew. And Arnold Fruchtenbaum is an evangelist to the Jews. And one of the things he talks about is that if you study the teachings of the rabbis, many of them believed that there would be two messiahs. One of them was the Son of David Messiah, the conquering, valiant warrior king like David, who would come with a sword in his fist and would bring peace to the nations by conquering them. But the other Messiah they imagined would need to come, because they could not imagine both roles being accomplished by one person, they called the Son of Joseph. The Son of David, and the Son of Joseph.

They pointed back to the story of Joseph, this example of one who was appointed by God as special, as set apart, whose brothers, the tribal heads of the Jewish nation, hated him, rejected him, laid hands on him, stripped him of his garments, threw him in the pit. We talked about this last week. And then from there he was sold into slavery, where he descended all the way into the pit of the prison, resembling hell itself. And from there he was lifted out to the right hand of the ruler of the time, Pharaoh, where he became a powerful ruler and saved the world by keeping many people alive, providing food for them. And they pointed to that suffering servant as an example. They couldn’t see how that would look anything like the Son of David; they couldn’t imagine how those two individuals would be the same person. But they understood that the example of the Scriptures pointed to the necessity of a suffering, rising Messiah.

But what about the resurrection? Do the Scriptures of the Old Testament teach by precept that the Messiah must rise from the dead? Yes, the apostles preached this all over the book of Acts. In Psalm 16:10: “For you will not abandon my soul to Sheol, or let your holy one see corruption.” (Sheol: the grave). It was written by David a thousand years before Jesus walked the earth. And as both Peter and Paul point out, David is still in the grave. David’s soul, his life, was abandoned to Sheol. David’s flesh did see corruption. David wrote not of himself, but about his greater Son, the Messiah, Jesus Christ, whose flesh would not see corruption but would rise from the dead on the third day.

And indeed, even the days are foretold in the Scripture, in Hosea chapter 6, verse 2. The people of Israel are speaking collectively, but in a voice that foreshadows Jesus, where they say, “After two days he will revive us; on the third day he will raise us up, that we may live before him.” As the Scriptures teach, it was necessary for the Christ to suffer and to die and to rise again. And what Paul and Silas are pointing to, what I am pointing to from their writings today, is that the only one who has ever lived to fulfill these promises—promises that were made seven hundred years and a thousand years and more than a thousand years before the coming of Christ—the one in whom this has been fulfilled is Jesus of Nazareth, whom I proclaim to you is the Christ.

And Paul and Silas, preaching this, declare it to people, and many come to faith. But again, we are seeing that pattern, where others are violently opposing him, especially this poor man named Jason. We don’t know anything about Jason except what we read about here. We don’t even know entirely if they lodged with Jason or if he just was the wrong man in the wrong place at the wrong time, if he’s sort of like the man who was forced to carry Jesus’ cross just because he happened to be there. But this Jason is dragged before the authorities, and he’s beaten and he’s tossed about, and he has to pay some kind of security deposit to make sure that these riots aren’t going to happen again. And only then is he released.

We don’t know that what they are saying is true, because they make up a lot of things in opposing and accusing the believers. But one thing they do get right is in verse 6: “These men who have turned the world upside down have come here also … and they are all acting against the decrees of Caesar, saying that there is another king, Jesus.” Jesus is the king. They got that right. Jesus is the one overturning the world, turning the world upside down. And this same Jesus of Nazareth is the reigning, valiant warrior, the Son of David Messiah, precisely because he walked the path of the Son of Joseph, who descended all the way into the pit and then was raised up, and is now seated at the right hand, not of the ruler of Egypt, but at the right hand of God the Father Almighty, Creator of all things and Judge of the living and the dead.

The question I want to ask you is this: why was this necessary? Why was this necessary? I was praying about this this morning. I went on a walk and was reflecting on this and was praying. Why was it necessary? Is there some compulsion, some constraint, some obligation that has been set upon God by someone else? Did we put this on God, and he said, well, I guess I have no choice? And the answer is no. God is the eternally blessed one. God would be eternally blessed and satisfied and joyful if he simply let us alone, to go in the way, in the footsteps, of our sin, all the way to death and eternal condemnation in hell. This would not harm God in the least, because God cannot be harmed. God cannot suffer.

And yet it was God’s good pleasure—out of nothing more than his free mercy, out of his love for the creation that had been tarnished, out of love for the people that he foreknew before their creation, out of love for the glory that he would gain by descending into the pit in the person of his Son and dying and rising again from the grave—that he sent his Son into the world: born of a virgin, according to the prophecies of Isaiah; despised and rejected by men, again prophesied in the Scriptures; pierced for our transgressions, crushed for our iniquities, again as the Scriptures foretold; dead and buried in the tomb of a rich man, as was prophesied in Isaiah; but risen again on the third day.

From the Scriptures of the Old and the New Testament, I proclaim to you that God has accomplished in the man Christ Jesus not something he was forced to do by anything outside of himself, but something that God bound himself to do according to his oath and his covenant and his promise. And this necessity he revealed and foretold in the Scriptures of the Old Testament. And so, I proclaim to you that the long-awaited Messiah is Jesus, and he has come, and all of you who put your faith in him will be saved. This is the hope we have: that the Lord of glory, the God who is over all, took upon himself a human nature, and suffered and bled and died in our place. The God who cannot suffer, the God who cannot die, became human so that he could, for us.

Right Response (Acts 17:10–15)

Well, from this message, from the hope of the Scriptures proclaimed in Thessalonica, for which Paul and Silas suffered and were run out of the city, what should our response be? And that answer comes in the second section, in Berea. We read in the second section of the right response, in verses 10 through 15, that “the brothers”—the believers in Thessalonica, that fledgling Thessalonian church to whom Paul would correspond in 1 and 2 Thessalonians—“immediately sent Paul and Silas away by night to Berea, and when they arrived they went into the Jewish synagogue.” Again, it doesn’t say as was his custom, but we should be picking that up. Salvation is from the Jews. Paul never lost his heart for reaching the Jews with the gospel of Jesus.

And we read that in this case, “these Jews were more noble.” The word here has to do with good breeding. It means a refined quality, rather than the rabble that we read about, who stirred up the mob back in Thessalonica. This is the idea of those who were serious-minded, who were open-hearted, who wanted to hear specifically what the Scriptures taught. And they were more noble than those in Thessalonica. Why? Because they received the word and examined the Scriptures daily. One commentator pointed out (I hadn’t thought about this) that this actually stands in contrast with the Thessalonians, where Paul met with them on three Sabbath days. We don’t even know if they were consecutive Sabbath days. You get the impression that those in Thessalonica were good pew-sitters in the synagogue, but the Scriptures never really touched them.

But here these Jews are receiving the word “with all eagerness,” and they don’t wait until the next Lord’s Day. They don’t wait till the next Sabbath to hear more about this. They go straight to the Scriptures and say, are these things true? Is the Messiah prophesied and foretold not just as a valiant, reigning, conquering Son of David, but would he actually suffer and rise from the dead on the third day? And they examined “the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so.” And when the Scriptures, not the preacher, but the Scriptures, convinced them that these things were so, “many of them therefore believed.” And this reached up into high society, “not a few Greek women of high standing as well as men,” though this would not contribute to their high standing, though this would not gain them votes or influence or prosperity. Yet they left those things behind, forsook them, in order to follow Jesus.

And yet here too, that cycle finishes its course, as we read about opposition. This time, however, it comes not from inside Berea, but the word travels back to Thessalonica, and they learn that the men who had turned the world upside down had come to Berea as well, and they were turning the world upside down in Berea too. And so “they came there too.” Not to study the Scriptures, not to examine the Scriptures to see if these things were so. They came “agitating and stirring up the crowds.”

Well, again, this is their cue. This is the time to leave. This is when they head off. And we read in verse 14 that they apparently had to do this in a staggered way: “Then the brothers immediately sent Paul off on his way to the sea, but Silas and Timothy remained there.” We don’t know if that’s for safety or to continue ministering in this fledgling young congregation. But in verse 15, we read, “Those who conducted Paul brought him as far as Athens, and after receiving a command for Silas and Timothy to come to him as soon as possible, they departed.”

Now, two things. One is that we are seeing the roles of Silas and Timothy. This is the role that Titus has. It’s the role that Scripture calls the role of an evangelist. These are the officers: apostles, prophets, evangelists. These are the evangelists, and their role was to come behind the apostles and to help put in order whatever remained out of order, wherever the apostles had left when they had to go on to the next place. And they had an extraordinary impact in the early church. So, we are seeing part of what is happening there. But the other thing we are reading is that the gospel has now landed in Athens. And we are going to read in the next passage about what that looks like. We’ve seen what it looks like for the gospel to be preached in the streets, in the temple of Jerusalem. Now we are going to see what happens in that ancient center of human learning and civilization and philosophy and arts and sciences and mathematics. What does the gospel have to say there?

Well, before we get to that, let’s remember the theme for today. I want to call you to respond to the Scriptures by faith. Not to me: to the Scriptures. One commentator, Lenski (I love him so much), writes this: “The shining way of faith is to receive the preached Word with all eagerness—not with hostility, and to test and to examine every bit of it by the Scriptures and to accept only what agrees with them.”

Earlier, I pleaded with you to believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household. But now let me add a qualifier that does not detract from that message. It reinforces that message. Do not believe because I have preached something to you. Examine these things according to the Scriptures. Be eager. Look at these things daily. Ask yourselves, are these things so? And I would say, believe in the Lord Jesus only if he is what the Scriptures proclaim.

Ask yourself: does God indeed promise, in Genesis 3:15, that he will crush the head of the serpent by the seed of the woman, whose heel would be bruised in the process? Do the Psalms, written a thousand years before Jesus’ birth, prophesy that the Messiah would be forsaken by God, since they have pierced my hands and feet? Does Isaiah, writing seven hundred years before Jesus’ birth, prophesy that the Messiah would be pierced for our transgressions and crushed for our iniquities? If so—and the Scriptures do—then believe in the Lord Jesus, whose hands and the heels of whose feet were pierced for you.

Does the prophet Isaiah declare that he would be buried in the grave of a rich man, in Isaiah 53:9? Do the Psalms promise that God would not abandon the Messiah’s soul to Sheol or let his Holy One see corruption, in Psalm 16:10? Does Hosea, writing five hundred to six hundred years before the coming of the Messiah, prophesy that God would raise the Messiah up on the third day, in Hosea 6:2? And does Jonah’s example, the example of three days and three nights in the belly of the great fish, set a pattern that the Messiah fulfills when he is in the heart of the earth for that same time, as Jesus says in Matthew 12:40? If so—and the Scriptures do—then believe in the Lord Jesus, who suffered, who died, who was buried, and who rose again on the third day.

Give yourselves to these truths. This is what we are in this world for. All the good things that we enjoy in this world, all of the hardships that we must endure in this world, all of this is for Christ. All of this is a theater for his glory. All of this is so that the world at the end of the ages might gaze upon the one who was pierced and see him ascended and glorified, when he comes on the clouds to establish his eternal throne in the new heavens and the new earth forever. Will you be there? Will you be his servant, his brother, his friend? Or will you be cast off forever into the outer darkness of hell and the torturing fires of condemnation, because you have resisted the Messiah who loved you to the point of shedding his blood for sinners like you? Turn from your sins. Believe in the Lord Jesus. Respond to the Scriptures in faith, and you will be saved, you and your household.

Get next week's study by email

Mondays: the study, the PDF and the sermon.