Jacob Gerber Subscribe

Photo by Andrew Seaman on Unsplash

The study notes, commentary and other resources for this passage are on 1 Corinthians 14:1–40: Orderly Public Worship: Part 3.

1 Corinthians 14:13–19

Therefore, one who speaks in a tongue should pray that he may interpret. For if I pray in a tongue, my spirit prays but my mind is unfruitful. What am I to do? I will pray with my spirit, but I will pray with my mind also; I will sing praise with my spirit, but I will sing with my mind also. Otherwise, if you give thanks with your spirit, how can anyone in the position of an outsider say “Amen” to your thanksgiving when he does not know what you are saying? For you may be giving thanks well enough, but the other person is not being built up. I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you. Nevertheless, in church I would rather speak five words with my mind in order to instruct others, than ten thousand words in a tongue.

Listen to the sermon

Harvest Community Church · preached September 13, 2020

Worship is participation-based, not performance-based.

  1. Praying to Interpret (1 Corinthians 14:13–15)
  2. Building Up the Outsider (1 Corinthians 14:16–17)
  3. Speaking in Tongues vs. Instructing with the Mind (1 Corinthians 14:18–19)

For the last few months, we have been studying 1 Corinthians chapter 12 through 14. And as we’ve been looking at this, we’ve seen Paul’s instruction about spiritual gifts in the church. We saw in chapter 13 about the way that love is supposed to guide the way we exercise our spiritual gifts in the church. And now in fourteen, we’ve been studying a very specific issue that has arisen in Corinth, a very specific problem, issue that’s been troubling and plaguing the church. And Paul is trying to write into this situation, to use what he said about spiritual gifts, to use what he said about love, to give this church practical information about how to deal with this specific issue that they’re dealing with, namely, that there are people who are in the middle of worship speaking in tongues, in other languages, without any translation. So it’s impressive, it looks interesting, it’s exciting in some ways, and yet no one else can benefit from it because they cannot understand what is spoken.

Well, this is our third sermon where Paul has been giving reasons why this shouldn’t be done in the worship of the church, the public worship of the church. And I hope that what we’re beginning to see is that Paul isn’t just giving the same answer again and again by using different words. Each time, each paragraph essentially, Paul is giving us a new reason that is important not just for us to understand historically what was happening back then, but each time he’s appealing to a general principle, a timeless principle that influences not just why Paul was saying what he said to the Corinthians, but that influences and should guide and shape our own worship today.

The issues throughout the history of the church always have changed, and they will continue to change. We will always be facing new questions, new challenges, new issues that arise. Think of all the huge disruption that these last few months have posed. So how do we answer these? Well, God doesn’t give us new revelations to answer questions specifically. He gives us principles from his Word, and we’re supposed to look at what God is saying here about this situation, this unique issue in Corinth, and draw out of these the principles that guide us and answer our questions even today.

So, last week we looked at one principle that had to do with the critical issue of the mind in worship, that our minds must be engaged with the Word of God. If our minds are not engaged with the Word of God, then we don’t have biblical worship. Now, our hearts must respond to the Word of God, our hands must be motivated to serve, but those come in priority after the mind. If your mind is not engaged with the Word of God, you don’t have biblical worship.

Well, that may raise a question. You may have been wondering last week or now, does that mean that only those who are the elites in the area of knowledge are able to benefit anything from worship? And that’s the issue that Paul takes up in this passage today. Paul is saying, okay, the common, the ordinary, the beginning Christians, especially the children in our midst: should worship just go over their heads? And the answer is absolutely not. And so, Paul here gives us another fundamental principle for our worship guiding how we should think about common ordinary Christians. He is going to talk about them here, as well as an aspirational goal for where we should go together as a church in our worship.

So, our big idea, this is the principle that we are unveiling or unearthing here. The principle, the big idea today is that worship is participation-based, not performance-based. Worship is participation-based, not performance-based. And so, there are three sections for this sermon. The first section is in verses 13 through 15, praying for fruitfulness, praying for fruitfulness, in verses 13 through 15. Then, the second section in verses 16 through 17 is about the participation of every member, the participation of every member. And then third, in verses 18 and 19, we have planning to teach, planning to teach.

Praying to Interpret (1 Corinthians 14:13–15)

So, let’s look in verses 13 through 15 at this first issue of praying for fruitfulness.

Again, Paul has been arguing up to this point against the use of untranslated tongues in worship, untranslated languages in worship. And now in verse 13, he wants to sort of say, okay, so, if you do have this gift of speaking in tongues, that doesn’t mean you have nothing to offer the body of Christ in a public worship service. Here is how your gift can be beneficial to others beyond just you. He says in verse 13, “Therefore, one who speaks in a tongue should pray that he may interpret.” Whoever has this gift of praying in tongues, Paul says, that’s okay. Here’s the way to use this for the benefit of others. You should pray for the ability to interpret what you are saying.

Now, the idea of interpreting what is spoken in tongues has come up earlier. It was back in verse 5 where Paul essentially said that to translate what is spoken in tongues is essentially to convert this speech in tongues into prophecy. Look back a little bit up the page at verse 5. Paul says, “Now I want you all to speak in tongues, but even more to prophesy. The one who prophesies is greater than the one who speaks in tongues, unless someone interprets, so that the church may be built up.” So the one who is speaking in tongues builds himself up, but Paul is saying it has to go beyond this. If you’re speaking in tongues, you need to pray for the ability to interpret. And so he goes on in verse 14 to say this: “For if I pray in a tongue, my spirit prays but my mind is unfruitful.” My spirit prays, but my mind is unfruitful.

Now, that may sound on the surface as though Paul is saying, my mind is barren, my mind is blank, I’m not getting any benefit in my mind from what’s happening. My spirit is doing something and my mind is suspended. But what he’s really talking about in the whole context is what he’s talking about. He’s not concerned about the benefit that he is getting from speaking in tongues, he’s concerned with the benefit that everyone else gets. If you look at the word fruitful in the Bible, the way it’s used throughout the Bible, it’s always talking about what is the fruit that you’re getting from your work with other people. How are people growing? How are people being benefited? How are people being built up? And this is exactly what Paul wrote back again up the page in verse 4: “The one who speaks in a tongue builds up himself”— your spirit is built up— “but the one who prophesies builds up the church.” That person is using their mind, not trying to get a benefit for themselves, but using their mind to interpret what they are speaking in a tongue to benefit the whole church, to bring fruit from the whole church. The point is not the one who is speaking in tongues needs more. The point is that the church needs more. There is an important part of worship that involves the participation of everyone.

Building Up the Outsider (1 Corinthians 14:16–17)

Now, what Paul says in the next section, in the second section, in verses 16 and 17, really shows us where his concerns are. Again, it’s not that the one who is speaking in tongues, their mind might be blank. That’s not his concern. His concern is for everyone else who is listening to this happen.

But again, as Paul is addressing this specific issue, in verses 16 and 17 is where we see this timeless principle, this bedrock principle that should shape and guide our worship. So, let’s look at what Paul says in verses 16 and 17. Here Paul emphasizes, again, we’re calling this the participation of every member. Look what he says. In verse 16, Paul says, “Otherwise.” So, he starts this section by illustrating what the negative consequence would be if I don’t pray to interpret what I am speaking in tongues or if I don’t pray or praise with my mind. Otherwise— if that does not happen— “if you give thanks with your spirit, how can anyone in the position of an outsider say ‘Amen’ to your thanksgiving when he does not know what you are saying?” The problem isn’t that my mind will lie blank and fallow and gain nothing from me. The problem is that the one in the position of the outsider won’t be able to participate. They won’t be able to respond. They won’t be able to say amen to what is prayed.

But who is this person, this one in the position of an outsider? Well, to answer that question, look a little bit down the page to verses 23 and 24. Paul uses this term again twice. In verse 23, Paul writes, “If, therefore, the whole church comes together and all speak in tongues, and outsiders or unbelievers enter, will they not say that you are out of your minds? But if all prophesy, and an unbeliever or outsider enters, he is convicted by all, he is called to account by all, the secrets of his heart are disclosed, and so, falling on his face, he will worship God and declare that God is really among you.”

So, who are these people? Well, Paul is saying they’re similar in some ways to unbelievers, but they’re different, similar but different. So, the word here is the word idiōtēs. This is the word that we get our word idiot from. I told my wife this is the first time I can legitimately use the word idiot in a sermon. But this word idiot is similar in the way that we use it in English, but pretty importantly different from what this word means here. Similar to our use of the word, this word idiōtēs refers to a lack of knowledge or training or specialization. But unlike our English word, this isn’t an insult. Paul isn’t here giving you free rein to call other people idiots and appeal to this verse. It’s a word that means maybe something like layman. To call someone a layman is not to insult that person. It’s simply to acknowledge a fact. You don’t have specialization or training in this area unless, of course, the person thinks that he does have training in that area and then they might take it as an insult.

But there are a couple of other places in the Bible that help us to understand what Paul is really after here. The idea that he’s trying to get at that’s helpful for the way that we think about our worship.

So, the first verse where this word comes up again is in Acts chapter 4, verse 13. This is a pretty famous verse. “Now when they”—the religious leaders—“saw the boldness of Peter and John, and perceived that they were uneducated, common”—that’s that word, or untrained, idiōtai—“men, they were astonished. And they recognized that they had been with Jesus.” These were laymen. They didn’t go to the fancy schools. They didn’t study under the fancy rabbis. Where was their training? Under a common carpenter, the Lord Jesus Christ. They had been with Jesus. Second Corinthians 11, verse 6 is another place where this word shows up, and Paul uses it in reference to himself. He is not calling himself an idiot. He is saying, “Even if I am unskilled”—idiōtēs—“in speaking, I am not so in knowledge; indeed, in every way we have made this plain to you in all things.”

Paul is talking then about anyone in the congregation, especially young, ordinary, common Christians who do not understand what the elites are doing when they are speaking in tongues. The elites are benefiting. They’re praying in their spirit. They’re showing off their spiritual giftedness. But these people, those in the position of the outsider, don’t have the ability to follow along, neither by natural learning nor by supernatural gift. Are they able to understand what’s being spoken in these prayers? Simple, ordinary, ungifted, and unskilled Christians. And if you have an ESV Bible, the ESV translation, you may notice that the footnote for that word is “Or of him that is without gifts.” This is someone that is ungifted, that is unskilled, that is a layman in these kinds of things.

Now, again, Paul is addressing a specific issue that came up in Corinth. He’s trying to pastor them through this specific issue. The issues will always change. The principles are what are important. So, from this specific issue, here is the fundamental principle that we should take from this, that Paul is deeply concerned with building up the simplest believers in worship. Worship is not, cannot, should not, must not be for the elites alone to benefit from it. Paul is burdened that even the one who is on the fringe of the church will be built up by what is happening in the worship, able to participate especially by offering his amen in response to the prayers, which would require him to understand what is spoken in those prayers.

Speaking in Tongues vs. Instructing with the Mind (1 Corinthians 14:18–19)

Well, in the third and final section, the last couple of verses, verses 18 and 19, Paul takes this general principle and tries to draw some practical applications from it. Okay, if we think that everyone should be participating in worship, everyone should have the ability to follow along and to respond uttering their amen in prayer, what should we do to bring along, to help those who are common, ordinary, who are young in their faith, the beginners in the Christian faith? What should we do for them? And in these last two verses, Paul tells us exactly what we must do. We must teach them. We must instruct them.

So, this third section is planning to teach. This is Paul’s game plan here. He is planning to teach. He wants this to happen in worship, teaching to happen in worship. So, look at verse 18. Paul says, “I thank God that I speak in tongues more than all of you.” Now, stop there for a moment.

Paul says at this moment, he has kind of waited in his argument, to suddenly say, don’t make a mistake here. Don’t think I’m opposed to speaking in tongues. I speak in tongues more than all of you. He’s waited for this moment to drop this piece of information. And this is an interesting piece of information. It makes sense because Paul is an apostle and the spiritual gifts were concentrated in the apostles. In fact, if you read the New Testament, especially the book of Acts, you see that these spiritual gifts were conferred to other people through the apostles. And so, that’s one of the reasons we think that many of these gifts died out with the apostles, because after the apostles faded away, there were no apostles then to confer these gifts for other people.

But I also wonder one thing. When Paul says this, it raises a curiosity in my mind, and I will acknowledge there is nothing more to support this than just what Paul says here and then a reading of the book of Acts, but I wonder if what Paul is talking about here gives us some insight into Paul’s great success as a missionary throughout the world. Remember that the gift of speaking in tongues was a gift to preach the gospel of Jesus Christ to new people groups who spoke other languages. On the day of Pentecost, when the apostles spoke in tongues, and this great multitude of people who spoke a great number of languages said that they heard the mighty works of God declared in their own tongues. And on that day, 3,000 people came to believe. And so, I wonder when Paul says this if he’s talking about his missionary experience.

You read the book of Acts, he travels and journeys and voyages all over the place to preach the gospel, to evangelize, to plant churches where the gospel of Jesus was not previously known. And in the ancient world, Greek would have gotten Paul a long way. The ancient world spoke Greek, similar to the way that we speak English in the world now. You can go a lot of places and English can get you by. When I was in Africa, I experienced this. When I was in Kenya, English allowed me to speak with a lot of people there who had learned English. And when I was in Rwanda, I speak some French and that got me along when I was there. But then you would find people who didn’t speak the major languages, the languages of trade and of commerce and things like that. They didn’t speak English. They didn’t speak French. They spoke Kinyarwanda and Swahili and then other languages that I don’t even remember what their names were because they’re only spoken by small tribes. The ancient world was like that. You wonder, was Paul speaking in Greek and that got him a certain amount of the way, but then as he’d come upon regions who spoke dialects or tribal languages, did he have the supernatural ability to preach the gospel of Jesus to them in their own tongues as happened on the day of Pentecost? I don’t know. There’s no way to know. It’s only speculation. It’s a curiosity about what this phrase might actually mean. Paul doesn’t say more than this, but it’s something worth thinking about.

What Paul really wants us to know, though, comes in verse 19. Paul says, “Nevertheless, in church I would rather speak five words with my mind in order to instruct others, than ten thousand words in a tongue.” Paul’s main concern is to instruct people. Whether simple or advanced, whether an outsider or someone who is heavily gifted, Paul wants to build up every believer who enters into corporate worship. He wants to preach, pray, and sing praises in such a way that even the simplest believers can make progress, can be built up, can benefit from what’s happening in the worship service.

Now again, the issues are different as we’ve been studying and talking about in chapters 12 through 14. The issues are very different because this was in the apostolic, the time of the apostles, where people still were prophesying, still were speaking in tongues. But now, even though the issues are different, even though we have the final Scriptures in the Old and New Testaments, the principle remains. We should try to build up every believer, even those who are just beginning their walk. And more than that, we should do this by teaching people, instructing them, rather than just speaking ten thousand words in a way to boast about our own spirituality or giftedness.

Application

So, how then should we take these general principles and apply them to our worship at Harvest Community Church in Omaha, Nebraska in the year 2020? Well, here’s the first practical application. Number one, keep the focus on Christ. Whether you are old or young, beginning or advanced, a preschooler or a pastor, keep the focus on Jesus Christ. What you need at every phase of your Christian journey is Jesus Christ and him crucified. God designed worship this way. The Father wants to put forward his Son as his image, as his representative, as the Word who reveals the Father to us, so that every knee may bow to Jesus Christ and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord. Because when that happens, the Father is glorified in the Son. This is to the glory of God the Father. And so, to bring this about, the Father and the Son together send their Holy Spirit, and his job is to open our eyes to see Christ’s glory, to open our ears to hear the Word of Christ, and to open our hearts to look to him by faith, so that as we look to Jesus, we look to the One who gives rest to our souls.

There was a call to worship that Bob led us in this morning: “Come to me, all you who are weary and laden.” Jesus is still saying this in this time of great upheaval, in this time of great violence and confusion and chaos. Jesus is still calling us to himself to give rest to our souls. And the only way for anyone at any phase of their Christian journey to be built up is by keeping our focus on Christ alone.

So, my question is, has your focus turned to Christ this morning? Christ has offered himself to you in his Word. Christ has made himself accessible to you in our prayers and as we respond to him by prayer and singing. Has your focus turned to him, or has your mind been checked out somewhere else? Are you believing then on him for salvation? Are you looking to him to know him, to love him? Keep the focus on Christ.

The second application is this, and this gets back at our big idea, the big principle that we find here, that worship should be participation-based, not performance-based. The difference is what everyone does versus what one person does for the enjoyment and observation of everyone. And God insists that Christian worship should be done with everyone involved, including those on the fringe, the outsiders, the common, the ordinary, the simple Christians. All should participate. All should offer their amen in worship.

So, let’s talk about both sides, performance-based and participation-based worship. What are we rejecting, and what are we trying to embrace? Well, in the early church, performance-based worship looked like people trying to perform their spirituality, show off in front of other people, by praying in tongues. The Spirit of God would come upon them and they would be enabled to speak in other languages that they did not naturally learn. And this would be amazing. It’d be extraordinary. And Paul forbids it in corporate worship unless there is an interpreter, because otherwise no one can benefit. No one else can benefit from it. Worship is not performance-based. The individuals praying may have been caught up in worship in their spirit, but their minds didn’t give one thought about how to draw other people in.

Today, this issue affects the way we think about those who lead in various parts of worship. Think about our singers. Our singers are not giving a concert, a performance for you to watch. You don’t come to hear the singers. They are up there to give help to people who are like me who can’t carry a tune very easily. So, they lead in helping us to find the melody so that our hearts can be singing and worshiping God and not worrying about the music. They are there to help us, to draw us all into worship. And what about the pastors or the elders as we lead in liturgy and in preaching? Well, we are not priests offering worship up and you are just sort of watching as spectators from a distance. We are there to draw you into worship. That is the performance-based worship that we are trying to get away from.

What does it mean then to design our worship with participation in mind? Well, this means that we want to be mindful of all those who are at the very beginning stages of learning to worship, new believers, outsiders, and children. And so, this means that we want our worship to be simple and plain, but that does not necessarily mean that our worship will be simplistic. Simple and plain, but not simplistic. That’s a tension, and we’re going to talk a little bit about that more in just one moment. But practically, what this means is that our prayers and our preaching shouldn’t sound as though an outsider were leading them. It shouldn’t be a lot of mistakes. It should be guided and accurate according to the Word of God. It should offer something real and genuine, but the prayers and the preaching should allow the outsider to say, amen, by being able at least to understand what’s happening.

Right now in the world, one of the biggest disruptions that is really making people angry with everything going on with COVID has been about sports. When you shatter people’s idols, they respond with a vengeance. And so right now, how are we going to play our sports is the big question that people are asking. And so, well, you can play sports and let the athletes compete and participate, and then just get the spectators out of the stands. Let them watch, televise from home. We have the technology to do that. That’s an acceptable way to play a game with no spectators in the stand. It’d be weird, but you can do it. The game still qualifies as a game. But in worship, it’s not that way. In worship, the only way for you to participate is not to watch as a spectator in the stand, but to respond, especially by giving your amen.

This brings us to our third application point, that we must use our minds to build up worshipers. Earlier, just a moment ago, I said that we want worship to be simple and plain, but that doesn’t mean that our worship should be simplistic. There is a tension here, right? If you want something to be understandable, the easiest way to do this is to give something to people at the lowest common denominator, to speak about the simplest things in the simplest language, and that works, but the Bible warns us against always giving watered-down milk instead of giving people real meat that they can sink their teeth into. The Word of God is a feast, and if we’re just sort of giving people a little diluted milk, we’re not giving them what they need. People need meat in order to be built up, in order to grow. So, how do you do this understandably and yet still serve a rich feast from God’s Word?

And this is where I think we get to one of the most important principles for thinking, especially aspirationally, what do we want our worship to be ideally? This is where we’re trying to move, where we’re trying to go each week as we gather together. It’s the principle Paul gives here of interpretation, this interpretation. Now, we don’t have other languages that are competing that we have to translate from something else into English this morning. That’s not what I’m talking about. But it’s an idea of not diluting the content, keeping the content level high. Remember, our minds must be engaged with the Word of God if it is to qualify as biblical worship. So, we want to give solid, edifying, rich biblical content, but we want to interpret it, to explain it in such a way that it’s understandable to all. I don’t claim that we do this perfectly. Every church is going to fall off on one side of error or another, but this is the aspirational principle that should guide us.

I mean, look, all of us really can learn more than we think we can. All of us can be stretched further than we think we can. You can go further in your Christian knowledge of the Lord than you think you can. But that requires someone else to interpret truths that are beyond us in such a way that it makes them understandable, so that we can palate it, so that we can digest it, so that we can grow and benefit from the meat rather than living forever on a perpetual diet of milk. We need to be stretched. And as worship leaders, our job, what we are striving to do— and if you have feedback about this, we get this a lot and we’re very interested in it— we want to interpret spiritual truths to those who are spiritual.

But what about you? What’s your role in all of this? Again, you’re not just a passive spectator watching what’s happening and counting down on your watch until things are done. Your job is to stay engaged. You don’t just watch. It can’t be a game if the spectators are not in the stands, because you’re not spectators. You are an integral part of what’s happening here. You have a critical role to offer your amen to prayers. The body of Christ must respond. Bob said, “And all God’s people said amen,” right? We prayed that today because it’s our job to respond to the prayers that we offer in the singing. We do that audibly sometimes, or you can do this silently whenever we offer these prayers.

Your job is to sing praises, not as a critic, not as someone who is disengaged and thinking about someone else, not as someone who is coming for any other reason but to engage with the text and to let the text guide and stir your heart. And even in preaching— we talked about this in the Westminster Standards class— you should be testing my preaching against the Word of God. In Acts chapter 17, verse 11, we read, the Jews at Berea were more noble-minded than those at Thessalonica because they searched the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so. Can you imagine Bible-checking Paul when he is preaching? But they were commended for doing so. It’s a great compliment when someone asks me, but Pastor, what about this? How does this fit with that? Because then I know that they were listening and not asleep, but then I also know that they’re trying to be good Bereans and they’re taking the Word of God seriously. I love those questions. Test the Scriptures. Ask me questions if you don’t understand.

Brothers and sisters, this worship that we are doing is not just to fill your schedules for an hour or so on a Sunday morning. This is a chance to be with the Lord Jesus Christ through his Word and by his Spirit. It’s not something that you’re watching from afar and wishing you could taste of it. It’s something you are participating in as you are responding to the understandable speech by offering your amen.