The study notes, commentary and other resources for this passage are on 1 Corinthians 14:1–40: Orderly Public Worship: Part 3.
1 Corinthians 14:6–12
Now, brothers, if I come to you speaking in tongues, how will I benefit you unless I bring you some revelation or knowledge or prophecy or teaching? If even lifeless instruments, such as the flute or the harp, do not give distinct notes, how will anyone know what is played? And if the bugle gives an indistinct sound, who will get ready for battle? So with yourselves, if with your tongue you utter speech that is not intelligible, how will anyone know what is said? For you will be speaking into the air. There are doubtless many different languages in the world, and none is without meaning, but if I do not know the meaning of the language, I will be a foreigner to the speaker and the speaker a foreigner to me. So with yourselves, since you are eager for manifestations of the Spirit, strive to excel in building up the church.
Listen to the sermon
The head is the only gateway to the heart and to the hands.
- The Benefit of Intelligible Speech (1 Corinthians 14:6–8)
- Intelligible Language (1 Corinthians 14:9–11)
- Eagerly Desire to Build Up the Church (1 Corinthians 14:12)
Among Christians, one of the most tragic points of contention that we have with one another is the subject of worship. Sometimes we call these the worship wars, where we debate and quarrel over, and all too frequently divide over, what should happen in the context of a worship service. Now, some of this is understandable. It makes sense. Our worship together, our corporate worship, the gathered-together worship of God’s people, is the most important thing that we do when we are gathered together. It’s the most important thing that we will do until Jesus Christ returns to inaugurate that eternal worship service over which he himself will preside. The Lord hasten the day for that. But in the meantime, as we are worshiping here and we’re trying to decide how to do this well, very often the debate shifts from what is central, what the Bible tells us to do in worship, to a lot of external matters, to issues of form or of style, rather than what the Bible tells us should be at the heart of our worship.
Now, to be really clear, the New Testament doesn’t give us a super clear set of instructions about what we should do in our worship. There is no New Testament equivalent to the Old Testament book of Leviticus. You can open Leviticus and find very detailed—overly detailed, sometimes we feel as we’re reading it—instructions about what you were supposed to do as an Old Testament worshiper, offering your sacrifices in the temple. We don’t have this. And so, when we consider what we are supposed to do, this passage has a clue. It has a principle that we need to listen to carefully, because it gives us the main focus that ought to occupy the primary place of our attention in worship.
Our big idea this morning as we look at verses 6 through 12 is this: that the head is the only gateway to the heart and to the hands. The head is the only gateway to the heart and to the hands. In worship, sometimes we’re asking first and foremost, What does my heart feel about what’s going on? Or, What am I being motivated to do as a result of this worship service? And the Bible says those are important questions, but the primary question that we have to ask first is whether the Word of God is coming in an understandable form into our heads. If it’s not, then it’s not biblical worship.
So, three parts to the text as we’re looking at it today. The first part is in verses 6 through 8. Paul tells us the benefit of God’s Word, the benefit of God’s Word. Then the second part is in verses 9 through 11, where Paul talks about the Tower of Babel, the Tower of Babel, and we’ll talk a little bit about why this refers to the Tower of Babel when we get there. And then the third part is in verse 12, the building up of God’s church, the building up of God’s church.
The Benefit of Intelligible Speech (1 Corinthians 14:6–8)
So, number one, let’s talk about the benefit of God’s Word that Paul talks about here in verses 6 through 8. Look at verse 6. Paul lays out his concern for the benefit of worship right away. He says, “Now, brothers, if I come to you speaking in tongues, how will I benefit you?” How will I benefit you “unless I bring you some revelation or knowledge or prophecy or teaching?” Now, Paul is concerned right up front. He lays this out. He is concerned that the worship of the Corinthian church should have some benefit. And so he has two things he is trying to say in this sentence. The first part of his argument is that untranslated tongues, untranslated languages among people who don’t speak that language, cannot provide any benefit to Christian worshipers, because they can’t understand it. That word cannot enter through the gateway of their minds. And so, because it can’t enter in through the gateway of their minds, there is no other way for it to provide a benefit to the worshiper. Now, Paul made a lot of that case in the first paragraph of chapter 14, which we looked at a couple of weeks ago.
So, the first part: untranslated tongues don’t benefit Christian worshipers. The second part of this argument, though, tells us what does benefit us. And he says that God’s Word is what benefits us in worship. Whereas we are concerned with a lot of these external issues of style and form, Paul says you should be interested in what is most important, the core, the central thing: the Word of God. And so he says God’s Word communicated in an understandable language benefits Christian worshipers, and he really lists two ways in which God’s worship should be centered around God’s Word. He lists four terms there: revelation, knowledge, prophecy, and teaching. But most people, when they look at these—and I would agree with this; I’m persuaded by this—see that Paul is actually talking about two different kinds of interacting with God’s Word, of exposure to God’s Word. There are two groups of two words here.
The first word group is revelation and prophecy, revelation and prophecy. Revelation refers to receiving—that’s the act of revelation—receiving the Word of God directly. And then prophecy is the act of communicating the Word of God that was received by revelation. Now, in the early church, this was happening right in front of Christian worshipers. Prophets would, in the middle of a worship service, under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, receive a direct word from the Lord that would cast some new light, that no Christian had yet heard, on who Jesus Christ was. What an exciting thing to have heard that! And so they would by revelation receive this word, and then they would preach or prophesy that word as an act of prophecy. So that is one part of receiving the Word of the Lord that Paul mentions here. In our context, we are not receiving new, fresh revelations from the Word of God. Rather, what we are called to do in worship is to read and to hear and to sing the straight, pure words of the Lord.
The second aspect of interaction with God’s Word is the word pair of knowledge and teaching, knowledge and teaching. Knowledge isn’t receiving a new word from the Lord. Knowledge is taking all the words that God has revealed in the Scriptures and by prophets, and taking all of those together and interpreting them, understanding them, organizing them, making sense of them. That’s the gift of knowledge. And then the act of teaching is the act of communicating the knowledge that arises from what we understand from the Scriptures. Now, again, in the original church, there were people who were gifted with the gift of knowledge, where they could hear what the prophets were saying from week to week, and they could put it together, guided by the direct work of the Holy Spirit, to make sure that what they were teaching as they communicated from their knowledge of the Word of God wasn’t moving off the mark. It was staying faithful to what God was revealing about his Son, Jesus Christ. Now, in our context, again, we’re not dealing with new revelation, but there is still an importance, as we have the final revelation of God’s Word in the Old and New Testaments, to learn it, to understand it, to interpret it, to organize it, and then to go on and preach and teach it. That’s, Lord willing, what I’m doing right now: to teach the knowledge of what God’s Word is trying to reveal from beginning to end.
And so these two ways of interacting with God’s Word—receiving the Word of the Lord, originally by the prophets but now by the Scriptures, and then receiving the knowledge and the teaching of the Word of the Lord as we preach and explain the Scriptures—these two kinds of exposure to God’s Word, Paul says, are central to worship. If you are not hearing the Word of the Lord purely, if you are not having the Word of God explained to you, then you don’t have biblical worship. It doesn’t matter what your heart thinks about it emotionally. It doesn’t matter what you’re prompted to do. Unless you have the Word of God, you don’t have biblical worship. God’s Word must first enter through the gateway of your head before it can influence and affect your heart or your hands.
Now, Paul goes on to solidify this point by making two illustrations. The first illustration comes in verse 7, and here he’s talking about the effect that the Word should have on our hearts, but through our heads. He says, “If even lifeless instruments, such as the flute or the harp, do not give distinct notes, how will anyone know what is played?” Now, in music—all of us know the power of music to stir our hearts, to stir our emotions. But remember, Paul is not just talking about music here. This isn’t music theory class. He’s giving us an illustration about the Word of the Lord. And he’s saying, Look, if you play a musical instrument, that can stir your heart, stir your emotions. There is beauty, there is emotion in music, but it doesn’t accomplish that emotional effect unless there are distinct notes that are played, unless the right melody is played. My children can bang on the piano keyboard, and that doesn’t stir the kind of emotions that music stirs. It may stir some emotions sometimes, but it doesn’t stir the kind of emotions that you would feel when a professional musician sits down to play a musical instrument. And so Paul, again, is not talking about music; he is talking about the Word of the Lord. Unless we hear distinctly the notes from the Word of God that are played, they can’t affect our hearts as God intended. That is the first illustration, to do with the heart.
The second illustration has to do with our hands. What should we do in response to the Word of God? In verse 8, Paul says, “And if the bugle gives an indistinct sound, who will get ready for battle?” Now, this is a military illustration. In the army, in the days before there was digital communication or even radio communication, commanders of militaries still had to communicate with all of their soldiers up and down the lines, if the battle changed in the moment, or even before, to prepare them for battle, which is what Paul is talking about here. People had to know what was coming, and the way that they would often communicate with large groups of people over a large space was by these trumpets. In fact, if you read Numbers chapter 10, you’ll find that the Israelites had just such a system. God commanded the Israelites to make two silver trumpets, and he gave them a very complex system of signals. If one trumpet plays, that means one thing. If two trumpets are playing at the same time, that means something else. If it’s a long blast, still another meaning. If it is short blasts, still yet another meaning. And what Paul is saying is, if the trumpets are not playing a clear blast, how will anyone know when it is time to prepare for war? Only if the trumpet sounds a clear signal can the army know what to do. Only when God’s Word enters the gateway of your head will your hands get any benefit from it.
So in this first section, Paul is telling us where there is benefit and where there is not benefit in worship. We get benefit in worship when we are exposed directly to the Word of the Lord, when we hear it by the act of prophecy—today, that means reading directly from the Word of the Lord, from the Bible—or when we have it explained to us by this act of teaching through the gift of knowledge, by preaching or teaching. Both of these ways are where we get the benefit. The primary benefit has to come in our heads as we understand this. But then through that primary benefit, through that gateway of our heads, our hearts and our hands can be stirred to do what God wants us to do in response to his Word.
Intelligible Language (1 Corinthians 14:9–11)
After Paul gives this initial statement with a couple of supporting illustrations, he moves on to the second section, where he takes this argument up. He talks now not just about general illustrations; he gives a really specific example of why this would be so devastating if people don’t have this clear, understandable Word of God in worship. And he points to the story from Genesis 11 of the Tower of Babel. Now, let’s look at what happens here. In verse 9, Paul doesn’t talk about the Tower of Babel right away, but in verse 9 he says, “So with yourselves.” In other words, he is taking what he said and he is summarizing it. “So with yourselves, if with your tongue you utter speech that is not intelligible”—that people can’t understand—“how will anyone know what is said?”
Now, Paul at this point anticipates an objection. Maybe someone says, Honestly, Paul, we don’t care if we can’t understand these people who are standing up and speaking other languages in our worship service. Honestly, it sounds amazing to hear other languages spoken. I know this feeling. I love going to big cities sometimes and seeing the cosmopolitan nature, where you hear people speaking all kinds of languages from around the world. That is really fascinating. But what Paul says is, as interesting as that may be, it has no benefit for the worshiper. And so he gives his first response to that objection at the end of verse 9. He says, if that happens, “you will be speaking into the air.” Your words will come out and they will just fall to the ground, and they won’t be of any benefit to anyone.
But then, in his second response to this objection, in verses 10 and 11, Paul brings us to the story of the Tower of Babel. Now, he’s doing a lot of referencing to the language of the original story as it was translated into Greek, and I’m not going to go into all of that right now. I would encourage you to get a copy of my sermon notes to see the careful way that Paul is clearly pointing us back to Genesis chapter 11. But let me just read this and then show you what Paul is doing with this, because it’s a really important point that he’s making here. In verse 10, he says, “There are doubtless many different languages in the world, and none is without meaning, but if I do not know the meaning of the language, I will be a foreigner to the speaker and the speaker a foreigner to me.” Now, if you’ve ever tried to communicate with someone whose language you don’t speak, you know this experience. This is a universal experience, trying to grunt and point and wave your arms to get some intelligible communication back and forth when the language doesn’t work. The other person is a foreigner to you. You are a foreigner to the other person.
But Paul isn’t just talking about a general experience that we all could probably identify with. He’s talking specifically about the Tower of Babel. Now, why the Tower of Babel? Well, let me show you what Paul is doing here. Remember the story of the Tower of Babel? At Babel, in the region of Shinar, a group of people gathered together and they made a plan. They made a plan to build a tower that would reach up to the highest heaven, to get to God. They did not trust the word that God had spoken to them. Instead, they decided to take matters into their own hands. God knew what they were doing. They were attempting to control God, and they were refusing to trust God. The act of building the tower at Babel was an act of rebellion against the word that God had spoken to them about what he wanted from them. And so God stopped the construction of the Tower of Babel dead in its tracks, and he did so by confusing their languages, so that each person was a foreigner to the other. This is verse 11: “I will be a foreigner to the speaker and the speaker a foreigner to me.” And that’s exactly what happens at the Tower of Babel. Each person becomes a foreigner to his neighbor, so they ultimately have to give up the construction of the tower.
So why does Paul tell us about this story and point so clearly to the Tower of Babel? Well, there are two warnings from this. The first is that Paul is reminding us of the solution that was given for the Tower of Babel. In the overall story of the Bible, beginning in Genesis 11, we see that originally humankind was connected as one people, but then they were split apart and fragmented into different people groups by their languages at that moment, as a judgment and a curse for their rebellion against God. Well, where all of this goes, and where all of this gets healed, where the cure to this curse comes, is in Acts chapter 2, on the day of Pentecost, when God initially gives this gift of speaking in tongues as a way of reversing the curse of Babel. Suddenly, the gospel of Jesus Christ was preached to a huge, diverse group of people speaking a huge, diverse group of languages, and they were all hearing the mighty works of God in their own native languages. That was the original purpose for the gift of tongues. And by that, if the initial act of separating people into languages came as a result of rebellion, by this giving of tongues God brought people back together through language, under the obedience of faith to the Lord Jesus Christ. And Paul says, You Corinthians, you’re misusing such a wonderful gift. You’re using this to show off your spirituality, but you’re plunging the church back into the confusion and chaos of Babel. What a terrible abuse of such a good gift.
The second warning that Paul is giving here we see when we take a peek ahead at verse 12. Look with me again at verse 12, the next verse, and look at the last phrase there. Paul urges them to “strive to excel in building up the church.” This word for building up shows up seven times in this chapter. It shows up again and again and again in this chapter because Paul throughout chapter 14 is portraying a worship service, just like what we are doing now, as a big construction project, a construction project to build up the church in love by the Word of God. And so here Paul is continuing this Tower of Babel metaphor, and he says, Don’t you know what happened to the people at Babel when they couldn’t communicate with each other anymore, when they were speaking foreign languages to one another? Ultimately, the construction came to a screeching halt. You’re doing the same thing to the construction project of building up God’s people in the worship of God’s Word in the church. Why are you doing this? The work, the mission of the church, cannot proceed when people do not speak the same language, cannot proceed unless God’s Word enters first through the gateway of our minds. What Paul is saying is that if the church recreates the chaos of Babel by untranslated languages, the construction project to build up the church cannot move forward. God’s people instead must have direct exposure to the Word of God in a way that enters first through their heads.
Eagerly Desire to Build Up the Church (1 Corinthians 14:12)
Well, in verse 12, Paul makes his final point. Up to this point, we’ve said much that says the Word of God has to be understood. It has to enter first into our minds. But Paul wants to correct a possible misunderstanding that we might have. He doesn’t want us to get the impression that Paul only cares about our heads, and that we should only worry about filling up our heads. Paul says, Not at all. Your head has to be connected to your heart. Your head has to be connected to your hands, or you don’t have true biblical worship. And so this brings us to verse 12. Notice that Paul starts verse 12 in the same way that he started verse 9, with the phrase “So with yourselves.” Paul is saying, Okay, take everything I have said. Here is the point I have been trying to make. And he is saying, What you need to see is the way in which the head is connected to the heart, and the head is connected to the hands.
And so first, Paul talks about our desires. He says, “So with yourselves, since you are eager”—eager—“for manifestations of the Spirit.” This word for eager is an important word in the context. If you look back up at chapter 14, verse 1, the first verse in this chapter, notice Paul says, “Pursue love, and earnestly desire”—that’s the same word there—“earnestly desire the spiritual gifts, especially that you may prophesy.” And then if you flip back to chapter 12, verse 31, Paul said, “But earnestly desire”—same word there—“the higher gifts.” Earnestly desire the higher gifts. Earnestly desire the spiritual gifts. And now Paul says, Earnestly desire the manifestations of the Spirit. He’s saying, This is a good thing. Your desires have been shaped by the instruction of the Word. I have been preaching and teaching to you about the way that the Spirit gives gifts to equip God’s people for building one another up in the Word of the Lord, and it is good and right for you to be eager for this. But now you need further instruction to continue to shape the response of your heart, not just to want manifestations of the Spirit because they are impressive in the context of worship, but for a very particular purpose: what you should be doing with your hands.
The last phrase here, Paul says, “strive to excel in building up the church.” Use all of your energy to do with these spiritual gifts what will build up the church. Now, there is no building up of the church unless God’s Word first enters our heads, but it is not enough for God’s Word to fill up our heads. God’s Word must go from our heads to transform the desires of our hearts, and from there God’s Word must drive the work of our hands.
Application
So what do we do with this? What are our applications here? Well, number one, our first application is this: understand the gospel of Jesus. What is the revelation that God has given his people through prophecy? What is the knowledge that God gives his people through teaching and preaching in the church? Well, the revelation, the knowledge that God wants to give to us, is the good news about Jesus Christ. And the Bible makes this clear in Revelation chapter 19, verse 10: “For the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” Everything that God communicates by the prophecies, by the promises, and even by the poetry in the Bible is all for the sake of introducing us to the Lord Jesus Christ. God wants to tell you in the Word that you desperately need Jesus, that on your own you are condemned before him as a sinner, without hope and without God in the world, and that there is nothing you can do to control him, like they attempted to do at Babel, to secure forgiveness from him.
But what the gospel declares is that God has done for you what you could never ever have done for yourself. The gospel is not about building a tower up to reach God. The gospel is what God has given down by his Word, the Word that announces his Word, his only begotten Son, who was born, who came into this world to die for you, so that God could purchase you back from sin and destruction. Throughout the Old Testament, God was always dropping hints, saying, My Son is coming. Get ready for him, in one way or another. But now the gospel announces that Jesus has come, that he was conceived by the Holy Spirit, that he was born of the Virgin Mary, that he suffered under Pontius Pilate. He was crucified, died, and was buried. He descended into hell. And on the third day he rose again from the dead, and he ascended into heaven. From thence he shall come to judge the living and the dead. Have you heard this revelation? Have you understood this knowledge? Has your mind grasped this? If so, have you believed this? Are you trusting in Jesus for your salvation? The promise of the gospel is that all those who turn from their sins and look to Jesus will be saved. Do you have that salvation? That’s what all of this is pointing to. Do you have it? Understand the gospel of Jesus.
Number two, build up your minds. Remember that 1 Corinthians 14 is addressing what should and what shouldn’t happen in the worship services of the church. And notice this chapter looks nothing like the debates we have when we engage in worship wars. Paul isn’t arguing about style and external issues of form. He is saying, Don’t drift away—Andrew preached about that last week—don’t drift away from what you have heard, from the central thing, from the Word of God. There is a reason that we spend so much time directly in God’s Word in our worship: that we read the Word, that we listen to the Word, that we sing God’s Word, that we pray God’s Word, that we confess God’s Word, that we preach God’s Word, that we even see, smell, taste, and touch God’s Word in the sacraments. This passage underscores the reason for that. It is not at random that we have chosen this. We need to be exposed to God’s Word. That has to be primary in our worship service, because the head is the only gateway to our hearts and to our hands. Unless the Word goes into our heads in a way that we understand and can be built up by, the heart cannot be moved, the hands cannot be motivated.
So let me put this as bluntly as I possibly can. Any attempt to worship God without first reckoning with the Word of God is not biblical worship. It doesn’t matter what feelings you’re feeling at the moment. It doesn’t matter how motivated you are to go do something. Any attempt at worship that tries to sidestep or come around the Word of God, avoiding the clear reading and hearing and understanding of the Word of God, is not biblical worship. Which means that when we talk about worship, we’re not always quite talking about what the Bible means when it talks about worship. Very often, we talk about worship as something that we simply feel: I’m worshiping because I feel something. Now, our feelings are not unimportant. I’ll say more about that in a moment. But when we talk about worship, and especially when we use “worship” as a shorthand for music, what we are communicating is that the reading of God’s Word and prayer somehow don’t count as worship, when the Bible says that’s the core of it. Getting God’s Word is worship.
The point, then, is that we should not ever try to take a shortcut to go directly to our hearts in a way that would bypass our heads. So in the music we sing, our philosophy of worship, which you can access on our website, says that we would rather sing robust theology to awkward music than sing robust music with awkward theology. We want to preach Jesus Christ in everything that we do, and especially in everything that we sing. Now, we want to have good music too, of course, but the point is that the primary consideration must be the Word. Any other stylistic consideration is at best secondary.
So when you are evaluating worship, when you are thinking about what you are supposed to be doing in worship, biblically we should be asking ourselves, What can I learn from this psalm? What revelation is here? What knowledge is here? And how do the words of this psalm drive me back to God’s Word? This is why we sing psalms and Scripture songs—we’re going to close with one a little bit later in our service—so that we can have the revelation of God’s Word directly, to sing it. But also, this is why we have hymns and spiritual songs, because hymns and spiritual songs, the other things that we’re commanded to sing in the Bible—psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs—give us a full understanding of all that the Bible is teaching us. They give us true knowledge of the gospel of Jesus. So, in sum, we need to ask, How is my mind built up by this song? Because unless the mind is built up, unless the gateway of the head is entered by the Word of God, the hands and the heart can benefit nothing. Let’s do everything we can in our worship to build up our minds.
Number three—and this is where we get at that possible misinterpretation—don’t hear me to say that our hearts and our hands are unimportant. The third application is to make sure that what you learn with your head transforms your heart and drives your hands. With all that we’ve been saying, that the head and the mind have to be of primary consideration as we think about how to get the Word of God into us, we must remember that the head is the gateway. It’s the gateway. I chose that word for a purpose. Because the gateway is not the end of the process; it’s the beginning. The point is not that you should loiter in the gateway. The point is not that you should do nothing but fill your minds. Paul says in this very letter that knowledge puffs up. If all you are getting is knowledge, all you are doing is puffing up your mind. You’re not letting it transform your heart and move your hands in the way that God intends it to. You’re short-circuiting the full purpose that God has for worship.
When you take God’s Word into your minds, that Word should be the fuel of your heart. That Word should be the catalyst to move your hands. God’s Word should affect your heart and your emotions, by cutting you down in sorrow for your sin and lifting you back up in the joy of God’s salvation. Moreover, God’s Word should fill your heart with the love of God until it overflows, spilling and splashing out onto those around you, so that in this way, as your heart fills up with the love of God, God’s Word is also training you for battle, for what to do with your hands—specifically, as he says in verse 12, to strive to excel in building up the church. God’s Word trains us and it equips us to serve our neighbor, especially our fellow members of the body of Christ in our local church.
What all of this means is that every week when we come into worship, we should really have three questions in mind. Number one, we should ask, What has my head learned or been reminded of from God’s Word? What have I learned? What have I been reminded of? But number two—and this is so important; without this we don’t have the fullness of the worship that God wants for us—the secondary consideration must be, Does my heart respond with appropriate emotions to what my head has learned? Am I just letting my heart go where it’s going to go? Am I just letting my head be puffed up? If so, neither of those things is biblical worship. My heart should respond to what I hear with my head. But then third, Do my hands learn and apply what I need to do to serve my neighbor? Am I striving to excel in building up the church?
Brothers and sisters, our worship service has a purpose. This isn’t to entertain you for an hour on a Sunday morning. This is for the great, grand construction project of God to build up his church in love and by his Word. Pay attention. Pay careful attention, lest you drift from the Word that you have heard. Stick to the Word of God, especially in our worship. Cling to it, so that we may strive to excel in building up the church.