Jacob Gerber Subscribe

My own understanding of the doctrine of the Trinity was significantly sharpened and deepened as I followed the controversy during the summer of 2016 surrounding the issue of the Eternal Functional Subordination of the Son (EFS), a doctrine promoted most prominently by Wayne Grudem and Bruce Ware. These debates drove me back to the classic texts of what the church has always taught about the Trinity, which were tremendously helpful in my own theology and love for our Triune God. I pray that this may help others to be edified as I was.

Additionally, I have purposely limited the scope of these discussions to what our Westminster Standards teach about the doctrine of God and the Trinity. There are numerous other resources, ancient and modern, that are helpful for these issues, but I have written this primarily for a presbyter or a presbyter candidate in the PCA. Beyond the Westminster Standards and the Bible, I would specifically commend three works: Augustine’s The Trinity (2nd ed., New City Press, trans. Edmund Hill), Christology of the Later Fathers (ed. Edward Hardy, Library of Christian Classics, John Knox Press), and John Calvin’s Commentary on the Gospel According to John. Augustine’s book is one of the most important books written in the history of Christianity, and the Christology of the Later Fathers is a collection of several of the most important documents written by the Nicene Fathers on the subject. John Calvin’s exposition of the controversial passages in the Gospel of John are extremely helpful for specific texts.

Westminster Standards on the Persons of the Trinity

The Westminster Larger Catechism #9 affirms exact equality between the persons of the Trinity, except on the basis of their “personal properties”:

Q. 9. How many persons are there in the Godhead?

A. There be three persons in the Godhead, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost; and these three are one true, eternal God, the same in substance, equal in power and glory; although distinguished by their personal properties. (emphasis added)

But what are those “personal properties”? Westminster Larger Catechism #10 answers that question:

Q. 10. What are the personal properties of the three persons in the Godhead?

A. It is proper to the Father to beget the Son, and to the Son to be begotten of the Father, and to the Holy Ghost to proceed from the Father and the Son from all eternity.

Notice that these distinctions of begetting (the Father), being begotten (the Son), and proceeding (the Holy Spirit)—are purely relational distinctions. In this, the Westminster Standards follow classical Trinitarian theology by acknowledging that some distinction exists between the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, but refusing to read anything into the ontology of those personal distinctions. The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit are not different beings, nor do they possess a different nature. The persons of the Trinity are “same in substance, equal in power and glory” as “one true, eternal God.” Significantly, this means that our confessional standards do not permit us to posit different functions or ranks to the persons of the Trinity within the Godhead in their nature.

To make this point even more clear, consider Westminster Larger Catechism #11:

Q. 11. How doth it appear that the Son and the Holy Ghost are God equal with the Father?

A. The scriptures manifest that the Son and the Holy Ghost are God equal with the Father, ascribing unto them such names, attributes, works, and worship, as are proper to God only.

EFS on the Trinity

The basic goal of Grudem and Ware’s doctrine of the Eternal Functional Subordination of the Son (EFS), on the other hand, is to give a more thorough explanation of what those relational distinctions mean. Historically, the church has refused to define these relationships in the ontological Trinity further than begetting and proceeding. The reason for this reluctance to define the intra-Trinitarian relations beyond relational distinctions is that God’s word does not give us much insight on these matters, so speculation has historically led the church into one kind of heresy or another. Nevertheless, Wayne Grudem insists that the names Father, Son, and Holy Spirit articulate the proper function of each person of the Trinity:

Thus, while the persons of the Trinity are equal in all their attributes, they nonetheless differ in their relationships to the creation. The Son and Holy Spirit are equal in deity to God the Father, but they are subordinate in their roles.

Moreover, these differences in role are not temporary but will last forever: Paul tells us that even after the final judgment, when the “last enemy,” that is, death, is destroyed and when all things are put under Christ’s feet, “then the Son himself will also be subjected to him who put all things under him, that God may be everything to every one” (1 Cor. 15:28).1

In Grudem’s view, the functions (i.e., works) of the Father are “commanding, directing, and sending,” while the functions of the Son are “obeying, going as the Father sends, and revealing God to us.”2 The important thing to notice is that Grudem assigns the privilege of “commanding” to the Father and the responsibility of “obeying” to the Son as inherent to their personal properties.

Bruce Ware (Professor of Systematic Theology at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary) takes this idea to its logical conclusion, articulating a view of the Father as the most glorious person of the Trinity:

God the Father receives the ultimate and supreme glory, for the Father sent the Son to accomplish redemption in his humiliation, and the Father exalted the Son to his place over all creation; in all these things, the Father alone stands supreme over all – including supreme over his very Son. All praise of the Son ultimately and rightly redounds to the glory of the Father. It is the Father, then who is supreme in the Godhead – in the triune relationships of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit – and supreme over all of the very creation over which the Son reigns as its Lord.3

This is perhaps the clearest expression of where the EFS doctrine deviates from our confessional standards, for in this Trinitarian scheme, the Father “stands supreme...over his very Son” in glory. Our Westminster Standards, however, insist that each of the persons are “equal in power and glory.” Under this scheme, the Son and the Holy Spirit are both unequal with the Father in their attributes, for the Father is supremely glorious within the Godhead.

Grudem goes on, writing:

Therefore, the different functions that we see the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit performing are simply outworkings of an eternal relationship between the three persons, one that has always existed and will exist for eternity. God has always existed as three distinct persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. These distinctions are essential to the very nature of God himself, and they could not be otherwise.

Finally, it may be said that there are no differences in deity, attributes, or essential nature between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Each person is fully God and has all the attributes of God. The only distinction between the members of the Trinity are in the ways they relate to each other and to creation. In those relationships they carry out roles that are appropriate to each person.

This truth about the Trinity has sometimes been summarized in the phrase “ontological equality but economic subordination,” where the word ontological means “being.” Another way of expressing this more simply would be to say “equal in being but subordinate in role.” Both parts of this phrase are necessary to a true doctrine of the Trinity: If we do not have ontological equality, not all the persons are fully God. But if we do not have economic subordination, then there is no inherent difference in the way the three persons relate to one another, and consequently we do not have the three distinct persons existing as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit for all eternity. For example, if the Son is not eternally subordinate to the Father in role, then the Father is not eternally “Father” and the Son is not eternally “Son.” This would mean that the Trinity has not eternally existed.4

Again, notice the differentiation of the persons of the Trinity on the basis of their roles—i.e., on the basis of their works, especially in terms of subordination within the persons of the Trinity. WLC #11 does not permit us to differentiate the persons of the Trinity ontologically on the basis of their works (or roles or rank), and to do so is to make the persons of the Godhead unequal with each other, regardless of Grudem’s insistence that the persons are equal in their ontology and only unequal in their role. That distinction is not one that our Standards permit us to make, and it is a distinction that orthodox Trinitarian theologians have rejected throughout the church’s history.

Essentially, Grudem tries to collapse the economic nature of the persons of the Trinity back into their ontology. This problem is at the heart of the error of EFS, and it is rejected by our Standards, as we will now explore.

The Economic (Externally Working) Trinity

Our Standards maintain a careful division in the way that we talk about the ontology (being, nature, essence) of the persons of Trinity versus the way we talk about their economic (that is, external) works. In their ontology, the persons of the Trinity are absolutely equal and only differentiated by their personal properties (WLC #9) of begetting (the Father), being begotten (the Son), and proceeding (the Holy Spirit; WLC #10). To suggest differences of attributes or works to the persons of the Trinity in either eternity past or in eternity future is contrary to our Standards.

In their external works, however, our Standards note that the persons of the Trinity do take on different roles and ranks. This is not because of something ontologically necessary to their personhood, but because of the free choice of God to act in a particular way in his works of creation and redemption. In particular, the Son took on an “estate of humiliation” in the language of Westminster Larger Catechism #42, 46–50:

Q. 42. Why was our Mediator called Christ?

A. Our Mediator was called Christ, because he was anointed with the Holy Ghost above measure, and so set apart, and fully furnished with all authority and ability, to execute the offices of prophet, priest, and king of his church, in the estate both of his humiliation and exaltation.

Q. 46. What was the estate of Christ’s humiliation?

A. The estate of Christ’s humiliation was that low condition, wherein he for our sakes, emptying himself of his glory, took upon him the form of a servant, in his conception and birth, life, death, and after his death, until his resurrection.

Q. 47. How did Christ humble himself in his conception and birth?

A. Christ humbled himself in his conception and birth, in that, being from all eternity the Son of God, in the bosom of the Father, he was pleased in the fulness of time to become the son of man, made of a woman of low estate, and to be born of her; with divers circumstances of more than ordinary abasement.

Q. 48. How did Christ humble himself in his life?

A. Christ humbled himself in his life, by subjecting himself to the law, which he perfectly fulfilled; and by conflicting with the indignities of the world, temptations of Satan, and infirmities in his flesh, whether common to the nature of man, or particularly accompanying that his low condition.

Q. 49. How did Christ humble himself in his death?

A. Christ humbled himself in his death, in that having been betrayed by Judas, forsaken by his disciples, scorned and rejected by the world, condemned by Pilate, and tormented by his persecutors; having also conflicted with the terrors of death, and the powers of darkness, felt and borne the weight of God’s wrath, he laid down his life an offering for sin, enduring the painful, shameful, and cursed death of the cross.

Q. 50. Wherein consisted Christ’s humiliation after his death

A. Christ’s humiliation after his death consisted in his being buried, and continuing in the state of the dead, and under the power of death till the third day; which hath been otherwise expressed in these words, He descended into hell.

Even though the Son existed in “the form of God” (Phil. 2:10), “being from all eternity the Son of God, in the bosom of the Father” (WLC #47), the Son took upon himself the “form of a servant” (Phil. 2:11; WLC #46). In the form of God, the Son is completely equal with the Father and the Spirit (WLC #9), but in the form of a servant, Christ endured an estate of humiliation that put him underneath the authority of his Father. The subordination of the Son to the Father is not an ontological reality inherent in the Son’s personhood, but an economic outworking of God’s plan of redemption for his people, where the Son took a subordinated role in the economy of salvation.

It is his form of a servant, then, that we can understand the words of Jesus when he posits a striking inequality between him and the Father:

  • “Truly, truly, I say to you, the Son can do nothing of his own accord, but only what he sees the Father doing. For whatever the Father does, that the Son does likewise.” (John 5:19)
  • “When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am he, and that I do nothing on my own authority, but speak just as the Father taught me.” (John 8:28)
  • “My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all, and no one is able to snatch them out of the Father’s hand.” (John 10:29)
  • “For I have not spoken on my own authority, but the Father who sent me has himself given me a commandment—what to say and what to speak.” (John 12:49)
  • “…the Father is greater than I.” (John 14:28)

These are not true of the Son in his divine nature, in the form of God, but only of the Son’s human nature in his incarnation, when he takes on the form of a servant during his estate of humiliation.

Moreover, it is in reference to the Son’s human nature through the incarnation that we correctly understand 1 Corinthians 15:28: “When all things are subjected to him, then the Son himself will also be subjected to him who put all things in subjection under him, that God may be all in all.” As Grudem understands this, the divine Son must transfer the subjection of all things to the Father because the Son (even in his divinity) is eternally functionally subordinate to the Father.

The Westminster Larger Catechism, on the other hand, sees the current exaltation of Christ as the exaltation of the “God-man,” “appearing in our nature”:

Q. 54. How is Christ exalted in his sitting at the right hand of God?

A. Christ is exalted in his sitting at the right hand of God, in that as God-man he is advanced to the highest favour with God the Father, with all fulness of joy, glory, and power over all things in heaven and earth; and does gather and defend his church, and subdue their enemies; furnishes his ministers and people with gifts and graces, and makes intercession for them.

Q. 55. How does Christ make intercession?

A. Christ maketh intercession by his appearing in our nature continually before the Father in heaven, in the merit of his obedience and sacrifice on earth, declaring his will to have it applied to all believers; answering all accusations against them, and procuring for them quiet of conscience, notwithstanding daily failings, access with boldness to the throne of grace, and acceptance of their persons and services.

It is as “God-man” that Christ subdues his enemies (WLC #54), and “When all things are subjected to him, then the Son himself [that is, the incarnate Son; the exalted God-man] will be subjected to him who put all things in subjection under him [that is, the Father], that God may be all in all.” If the Son must be subjected to the Father in his divine nature so “that God may be all in all,” then it is hard to avoid the conclusion that the Son is not fully God in the way that the Father is. As such, it is hard to avoid the conclusion that this doctrine is a soft form of Arianism.

On the contrary, 1 Corinthians 15:28 teaches that Christ’s human nature will be subjected to the Father so “that God may be all in all.” Far from teaching that these economic differences of the Trinity will last forever, this text teaches the opposite: the economic subordination of the Son in his incarnation (even in his human glorification) will ultimately run its course after all enemies are subdued, so that God may ontologically (i.e., in the equality of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit) may be all in all.

Divine Simplicity and the Persons of the Trinity

There is one more factor in how this teaching relates to the overall doctrine of God: Divine Simplicity. The Westminster Confession plainly teaches Divine Simplicity by stating that God is “without...parts” (WCF 2.1), which means that we cannot imagine God as though he were separated into different components that together make up God—in other words, he is simple. To give an analogy for the sake of contrast, consider that the human body is made up of many different parts—skin, bone, muscles, tissues, organs, etc.—where all of the parts compose the whole. As such, we are liable to change and damage, since any single one of our parts might break down, affecting the whole. For example, if our brain and lungs work perfectly but our heart gives out, we will still die, because our whole body is dependent on the constituent parts that make us up.

God is not like this—he is without parts, so that every attribute of God is the same thing as the totality of God. Kevin DeYoung (PCA TE) puts it this way:

By “simple” we do not mean God is slow or dim-witted. Nor do we mean that God is easy to understand. Simple, as a divine attribute, is the opposite of compound. The simplicity of God means God is not made up of his attributes. He does not consist of goodness, mercy, justice, and power. He is goodness, mercy, justice, and power. Every attribute of God is identical with his essence….

In other words, the simplicity of God not only prevents us from ranking certain attributes higher than others, it allows God to have “a distinct and infinite life of his own within himself” ([Bavinck, Reformed Dogmatics, 2:]177). He is not an abstract Absolute Idea who happens to have love, wisdom, and holiness, as if we first conceive of a being called God and then relate qualities to him. Rather, God in his very essence—within himself and by himself—is love, wisdom, and holiness. God is whatever he has. He is not the composite of his attributes, some in greater and some in lesser amounts. God is a simple being without parts or pieces. His attributes do not stick to him; he is what they are.5

By saying that God is “without…parts,” the Confession is teaching that God is not partly made up of love and partly made up of righteousness and partly made up of holiness. Instead, we confess that God is love (1 John 4:8, 16), and that God is righteous (1 Cor. 1:30; 1 John 2:1), and that God is holy (Isa. 6:3). “Love” and “righteous” and “holy” are not categories outside of God that we use to understand God; rather, God is his attributes—and if he isn’t, then he is not truly free, absolute, and independent.

This principle of Divine Simplicity is at the heart of God’s very name revealed to Moses: “I am who I am” (Ex. 3:14). God simply is what he is without any change, growth, development, or loss.

The Westminster Confession of Faith says this:

2.1. There is but one only, living, and true God, who is infinite in being and perfection, a most pure spirit, invisible, without body, parts, or passions; immutable, immense, eternal, incomprehensible, almighty, most wise, most holy, most free, most absolute; working all things according to the counsel of His own immutable and most righteous will, for His own glory; most loving, gracious, merciful, long-suffering, abundant in goodness and truth, forgiving iniquity, transgression, and sin; the rewarder of them that diligently seek Him; and withal, most just, and terrible in His judgments, hating all sin, and who will by no means clear the guilty.

2.2. God hath all life, glory, goodness, blessedness, in and of Himself; and is alone in and unto Himself all-sufficient, not standing in need of any creatures which He hath made, nor deriving any glory from them, but only manifesting His own glory in, by, unto, and upon them. He is the alone fountain of all being, of whom, through whom, and by whom are all things, and hath most sovereign dominion over them, to do by them, for them, or upon them whatsoever Himself pleaseth. In His sight all things are open and manifest, His knowledge is infinite, infallible, and independent upon the creature, so as nothing is to Him contingent or uncertain. He is most holy in all His counsels, in all His works, and in all His commands. To Him is due from angels and men, and every other creature, whatsoever worship, service, or obedience He is pleased to require of them.

What this means is that we cannot consider the persons of the Godhead to be constituent parts out of which the Godhead is composed. The Trinity is not three “people,” but three persons, for we are not dealing with a committee of three divinities, but a single God who exists as three persons.

This principle of Divine Simplicity is the reason that we cannot posit differences between the works and attributes of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit (WLC #11).

Additionally, the principle of Divine Simplicity is the reason that we cannot say that the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit each have a different will, judgment, teaching, or life. The Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit each possess the same will, judgment, teaching, or life, for there are not three who will, but One; not three Judges, but One; not three teachers, but One; not three Life-Givers, but One. God exists as three persons, but not as three parts.

The principle helps to understand the words of Jesus at various points in the Gospels. For example, how can Jesus truthfully say both that the Father judges no one and that he (Jesus) judges no one:

  • “The Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son, that all may honor the Son, just as they honor the Father. Whoever does not honor the Son does not honor the Father who sent him” (John 5:22–23)
  • “You judge according to the flesh; I judge no one.” (John 8:15)

The answer is that the Father judges in and through the Son, for there are not two (or three!) Judges, but only one Judge. So, in both of these passages, Jesus goes on to articulate the way in which the Father judges through the Son:

  • “I can do nothing on my own. As I hear, I judge, and my judgment is just, because I seek not my own will but the will of him who sent me” (John 5:30)
  • “Yet even if I do judge, my judgment is true, for it is not I alone who judge, but I and the Father who sent me” (John 8:17)

What, then, of the “will” that Jesus speaks of apart from his Father in John 5:30? Also, what does Jesus mean when he prays in the Garden of Gethsemane, “My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me; nevertheless, not as I will, but as you will” (Matt. 26:42). If the Father and the Son (with the Spirit) share a single will of the Godhead, how can the two have different wills here?

At the Sixth Ecumenical Council (the Third Council of Constantinople in 681), the church insisted that Christ possesses two wills in accordance with his two natures:

We also proclaim two natural willings or wills in him and two natural operations, without separation, without change, without partition, without confusion, according to the teaching of the holy Fathers—and two natural wills not contrary [to each other], God forbid, as the impious heretics have said [they would be], but his human will following, and not resisting or opposing, but rather subject to his divine and all-powerful will. For it was proper for the will of the flesh to be moved [naturally], yet to be subject to the divine will, according to the all-wise Athanasius. For as his flesh is called and is the flesh of God the Word, so also the natural will of his flesh is called and is God the Word’s own will, as he himself says: “I came down from heaven, not to do my own will, but the will of the Father who sent me,” calling the will of his flesh his own, as also the flesh had become his own.6

Will is connected to nature, so that Christ possesses one will according to his divine nature, and one will according to his human nature. The monothelite heresy, which argued that Christ possessed only a single will according to the unity of his personhood (instead of two wills according to his two natures) was condemned at this council as heresy. This Council was considered to be an extension and clarification of Chalcedon, which the Westminster Larger Catechism #37 reflects through the language of “reasonable soul”:

Q. 37. How did Christ, being the Son of God, become man?

A. Christ the Son of God became man, by taking to himself a true body, and a reasonable soul, being conceived by the power of the Holy Ghost in the womb of the Virgin Mary, of her substance, and born of her, yet without sin.

Also, Westminster Confession of Faith 8.2 states that the Son took upon himself “man’s nature, with all the essential properties,” where “all the essential properties” includes a human will.

The Trinity and Complementarianism

The final point to mention is that much of the reason that Grudem and others have insisted so firmly on the Eternal Functional Subordination of the Son has to do with a complementarian understanding of human gender. He takes the equality of men and women in nature and the distinctions of men and women in roles as a reflection of the ontological nature of the persons of the Godhead:

In fact, the relationship between man and woman in marriage we see also a picture of the relationship between the Father and Son in the Trinity. Paul says, “But I want you to understand that the head of every man is Christ, the head of a woman is her husband, and the head of Christ is God (1 Cor. 11:3). Here, just as the Father has authority over the Son in the Trinity, so the husband has authority over the wife in marriage. The husband’s role is parallel to that of God the Father and the wife’s role is parallel to that of God the Son. Moreover, just as the Father and Son are equal in deity and importance and personhood, so the husband and wife are equal in humanity and importance and personhood. And, although it is not explicitly mentioned in Scripture, the gift of children within marriage, coming from both the father and the mother, and subject to the authority of the father and mother, is analogous to the relationship of the Holy Spirit to the Father and Son in the Trinity.7

Without belaboring the point, we should simply remark that the passage from 1 Corinthians 11:3 is much better interpreted when we recognize that Paul is speaking of Christ in his role as mediator. Paul means that “the head of Christ is God” in the same way that Jesus says “the Father is greater than I”—not as though this were referring to ontological realities of the divine persons within the Godhead, but as an expression of the economic (external) work of the Son’s taking upon himself the role of a servant in humiliation and an exalted servant in his exaltation.

It is important that we not project roles of men and women in marriage back into the ontological Trinity. Instead, we follow the teaching of Scripture to recognize that the economic work of the Trinity teaches us something about the roles of men and women. So, wives are to submit to their husband as the church submits to Christ (Eph. 5:24), and husbands are to love their wives as Christ loved the church (Eph. 5:25). Then, when we speak of the way that wives ought to submit to their husbands, we can appeal to the submission of the incarnate Son in taking the form of a servant in his economic role as Christ (Phil. 2:11), so long as we do not project that economic subordination back into some inherent feature of the personhood of the Son within the ontological Trinity.

Notes

  1. Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House, 1994), 249. ↩

  2. Grudem, Systematic Theology, 250. ↩

  3. Bruce Ware, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit: Relationships, Roles, and Relevance (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2005), 50. ↩

  4. Grudem, Systematic Theology, 251. Original emphasis. ↩

  5. Kevin DeYoung, “Theological Primer: The Simplicity of God,” September 27, 2013. <https://blogs.thegospelcoalition.org/kevindeyoung/2013/09/27/theological-primer-the-simplicity-of-god/> Accessed May 11, 2017. ↩

  6. “The Statement of Faith of the Third Council of Constantinople (Sixth Ecumenical),” in Creeds of the Churches, ed. John H. Leith, 3rd ed. (Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 1982), 51. ↩

  7. Grudem, Systematic Theology, 257. ↩

Get next week's study by email

Mondays: the study, the PDF and the sermon.