Printable study notes
Introduction
If we imagined that Jesus would gently ramp into his public ministry with something non-confrontational to please the crowds and (hopefully) to start to win the favor of the authorities, we will be disappointed by the course of action Jesus takes. With the zeal of a Son who sees his Father’s house desecrated, Jesus cleanses the temple during a Passover feast, driving out the animals and the merchants who have trespassed to take up residence there for their own profit. As with the sign that Jesus performed in turning water into wine in the previous passage, the sign of cleansing the temple is filled with important symbolism that points beyond this single day at the temple. Jesus will cleanse the dwelling place of his Father, even though it will cost him his life.
What does Jesus’ zeal demonstrate about his identity and his mission? What should we learn from him as we see him drive out the merchants, the sacrificial animals for sale, and the moneychangers from the temple? How does this story fit together with the previous story of how Jesus turned the water into wine—and specifically, how does this temple purification tie in with the purification that the stone water jars at the wedding feast (John 2:6) had been intended for? Is Jesus destroying the most important institutions of God’s covenant with his people Israel, or is his work accomplishing something more than the disruption that we see here? Finally, how should we respond to reading about all this?
Sermon
Listen to the sermon
Theme: Jesus will cleanse the dwelling place of his Father, even though it will cost him his life.
Outline:
- The Passover Lamb of God (John 2:13–17)
- The Temple of God (John 2:18–22)
- Genuine vs. Fleeting Faith (John 2:23–25)
John 2:13–25
The Passover of the Jews was at hand, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem. In the temple he found those who were selling oxen and sheep and pigeons, and the money-changers sitting there. And making a whip of cords, he drove them all out of the temple, with the sheep and oxen. And he poured out the coins of the money-changers and overturned their tables. And he told those who sold the pigeons, “Take these things away; do not make my Father’s house a house of trade.” His disciples remembered that it was written, “Zeal for your house will consume me.”
So the Jews said to him, “What sign do you show us for doing these things?” Jesus answered them, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.” The Jews then said, “It has taken forty-six years to build this temple, and will you raise it up in three days?” But he was speaking about the temple of his body. When therefore he was raised from the dead, his disciples remembered that he had said this, and they believed the Scripture and the word that Jesus had spoken.
Now when he was in Jerusalem at the Passover Feast, many believed in his name when they saw the signs that he was doing. But Jesus on his part did not entrust himself to them, because he knew all people and needed no one to bear witness about man, for he himself knew what was in man.
I don’t remember the first time that I saw this, but I feel like I’ve seen it more and more over time. What I’m talking about is, maybe you’ve seen a movie or a television episode that for some reason doesn’t start right at the very beginning of the story. In fact, it doesn’t even start anywhere close to the beginning. It starts all the way at the very end of the story, thrusting you right into the middle of the action, the climax of the whole thing. And you’re wondering, why are we seeing this? What’s led up to this? And then they’ll sort of stop at that point, leave you at a cliffhanger, and back up to the beginning of the movie and head all the way back through.
Now, when you watch this, no one’s thinking, “Oh no, some little editor on the editing floor made a mistake and spliced the wrong part of film into this part of the movie.” That’s not what’s happening. The filmmaker, the director, the producer is making a very concerted, conscientious, informed decision to tell the story this way, by giving you a peek, a glimpse, into where everything is headed, for the purpose that as you are reading or watching everything that leads up to that, you know where everything’s headed. Characters that might otherwise have seemed insignificant suddenly take on pretty big significance. Little things that people say or do that you might be tempted to write off suddenly become of great importance. And the filmmaker, the producer, the director, the editor, the writer, whoever, wants it that way.
Now, it may be that that’s what we are encountering by reading the story of the cleansing of the temple here. Because if we just look at this story where it is in John’s Gospel of Jesus, it seems like John is telling us about something— again, we’re just sort of reading through, and we think this happened right after the wedding at Cana and right before Jesus talks to Nicodemus in John 3— then it looks like this story of the cleansing of the temple takes place at the beginning of Jesus’ public ministry. But in the Synoptic Gospels, in Matthew, Mark, and Luke alike, we don’t read of any kind of temple cleansing at the beginning of Jesus’ public ministry. We only read (and all of them are uniform on this) of a temple cleansing at the very end of Jesus’ life, during Passion Week, in the days leading up to the crucifixion of Jesus.
Now, some look at that and say, “Oh, that’s obviously an error. That’s a mistake. John didn’t know what he was doing. The Bible’s riddled with errors. Here’s just one more of them.” But if we can watch a movie and see a scene from the end pulled up front, and we don’t think that the editor has made a mistake, why should we think that here? It may be that there are, in fact, two cleansing stories. Some Bible scholars think that. Or it may be that John, at the very outset of Jesus’ public ministry, wants to put this story here, for a lot of reasons; we’ll unpack a few of them here this morning.
Whether there is one cleansing story or two cleansing stories in history, John frankly doesn’t care about arbitrating that dispute. I mean, John has already read the Synoptic Gospels. They were written before he wrote. He expects, he assumes, what’s in those. John doesn’t include the baptism of Jesus, doesn’t include the Transfiguration of Jesus, doesn’t include the Lord’s Supper. He says, you can get all that information in the Synoptic Gospels; I’m doing something different here. Which means that sometimes he plays with the chronological sequence of things. Maybe there are two stories, maybe not. But the main thing that we have to consider, one way or another, is what this story is telling us here. What does John want us to see? At this very early point in the Gospel, how does he want us to read the rest of the story, all the way up to the climax at the end, with understanding? This should be a lens that absolutely influences everything, that colors our reading of everything that follows.
And so in this story, John gives us three things. Number one, he tells us about a sign, a symbol. Number two, John tells us about the thing signified. A sign always points beyond itself to some greater reality that it signifies; there’s a reference point. So we have a sign, number one. We have a thing signified, number two. And then we have, number three, a significance: what does this story mean for those of us living today?
The Passover Lamb of God (John 2:13–17)
Well, let’s start with the sign. John doesn’t explicitly call the cleansing of the temple that Jesus does here a sign. But there’s no question that that’s what’s going on here: that Jesus, as he walks in and overturns tables and drives out money-changers and animals from the temple, is very deliberately performing a sign. And what Jesus is doing is gathering up all of the loose ends of Old Testament prophecies and laws and shadows and symbols, and he’s gathering them up and saying, I’m going to act out something in front of you so that you know that I am going to be the one to fulfill every last bit of this.
Now, the disciples catch some of the meaning at this point in time. As they’re watching this, in verse 17 we read, “His disciples remembered that it was written, ‘Zeal for your house will consume me.’” That’s a direct quotation from Psalm 69:9. So the disciples are remembering. They’re watching this, this Scripture comes to mind, and they say, “Whoa, Jesus is consumed with zeal for God’s house. This is what the Scriptures told us the Messiah would do, what the Scriptures told us the Messiah would be like.” Now, we’ll talk a little bit more about how the disciples are probably imagining what is actually happening in front of them, but let’s start there. So some of this is direct prophecy that the disciples recognize at the time.
But some of this is a little bit more complex. Notice that John says that this happens during the Passover of the Jews, in verse 13. That’s pretty important. You may or may not know the subtleties of how the Passover functioned in Old Covenant Israel. But every year, year after year, the people of God, the Israelites, were to celebrate the Passover Feast. Now, the Bible tells us in the Old Testament that there were significant stretches where the people of God went without celebrating the Passover Feast, and that was a bad thing. But for centuries and millennia, with only a few breaks in the process, every year, year by year, the Jews would gather together and remember the Passover, what God had done to bring his people out of the land of Egypt.
And the Passover feast was the first day of a seven-day feast, the seven-day Feast of Unleavened Bread. So the Passover is day one of the seven-day Feast of Unleavened Bread, which was a time when the Jews were not allowed to eat anything with leaven in their house. But it was actually more than that. It wasn’t just that they were supposed to put it away in a special cupboard and then bring it back out at the end. In Exodus 12:15, Yahweh, who’s instituting the Passover at the very beginning of the Passover, says, “Seven days you shall eat unleavened bread. On the first day” (the Passover day) “you shall remove leaven out of your houses, for if anyone eats what is leavened, from the first day until the seventh day, that person shall be cut off from Israel”: shall be excommunicated from Israel.
So what do we see Jesus doing? Well, leaven eventually became a symbol of evil and hypocrisy, malice. So Jesus said, “Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees.” Beware of the self-righteous, wicked teaching of the Pharisees. Paul in 1 Corinthians 4 says to the church at Corinth, there is a problem in your church. There is an unrepentant sin that no one has the courage to deal with. And he warns them, saying, a little leaven will leaven the whole lump. If you do not deal with this sin in your midst, then the sin, like leaven, will infect everything that it touches. The problem won’t go away; it’s going to multiply. Now, probably year after year of cleansing their houses of leaven, leaven started to seem to them like evil, and that’s why it acquired that kind of symbolism.
So it makes sense that here Jesus walks into the Passover, and what does he do? He cleanses his Father’s house, and therefore his own house, of the leaven of evil, of people who have started making money and price-gouging people right inside his Father’s house. Passover starts with cleansing your house. Jesus starts the Passover feast with cleansing his Father’s house, saying, “Do not make my Father’s house a house of trade.” That’s one part of what Jesus is doing here.
Another part of what Jesus is doing here is reminiscent of what John the Baptist had said about Jesus. You remember John 1:29? The Gospel of John is the only place where we read John the Baptist saying, “Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!” Well, we talked a little bit about what that lamb exactly refers to. I mean, are we talking about the ram whose horns were caught in the thicket, that was a substitute sacrifice for Isaac when God originally told Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac? Or are we talking about the lambs that were regularly offered in sacrifice as burnt offerings to the Lord? Or maybe what the prophet Isaiah talks about, the suffering servant who would be led like a lamb to the slaughter? Is that the Lamb of God that Jesus is? Or are we talking about the Passover lamb? Well, what we said a couple of weeks ago is that you can’t really parse out one specific kind of lamb, because to do so would miss the point. When John the Baptist points at Jesus and says, “Behold, the Lamb of God,” he’s saying that everything a lamb signified, Jesus gathers together and fulfills. And here we have Jesus, the Passover Lamb, going up for the Passover to give a sign.
Well, there’s just a little bit more to it than that. As he does this, notice what he says in verse 16. He says, “Take these things away.” Take away these things. This is the exact same verb that John the Baptist had used: “Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!” In other words, right here, right now, John the Baptist’s words are coming to fruition. Jesus, the Passover Lamb of God, is right here beginning the process of taking away the sin of the world. And it begins with the cleansing of his Father’s house. It’s beginning. The invasion into enemy-occupied territory has begun. The Passover Lamb of God is cleansing his Father’s house. This is a sign, again gathering together all of the symbols, all of the prophecies, all of the shadows of the Old Testament, and even the prophecy of John the Baptist himself. And Jesus is saying, I have come to be and to do everything that was anticipated of the Messiah.
That’s the sign that Jesus performs here, because what Jesus does here isn’t complete. It’s not like Jesus does this and says, “Well, my work here is done. I’ve driven out some money-changers from the temple. I’ve driven some animals out of the temple.” No, he’s saying, this in fact is a sign, a symbol of what I have actually come to do, but you need to see it. You need to recognize that this is who I am. You need to see my authority and begin to understand that what you are seeing here is symbolic of the larger reality that I have come to accomplish.
There’s one other prophecy that Jesus directly fulfills with this, and it’s one that we read in our confession of sin, from Malachi 3: “And the Lord whom you seek will suddenly come to his temple.” And then in verse 3 it says, “and he will purify the sons of Levi.” The idea is that God will come all at once, and it’s this idea of the day of the Lord, which will be a day of judgment and of calamity for the sake of purifying his people.
Now, here’s the thing. Before we move on, before we get deeper into what is signified by this sign that Jesus is performing, the first question we have to ask is, in what ways is Jesus bringing this kind of calamity into our own lives? I mean, this is the experience of the believer, right? You’re going along, and you have these things that you’ve learned to trust, places that bring you comfort, that you think are profiting you in your life. And what does Jesus do? The way that Jesus leads us is not one of comfort. It’s not one where he seeks to preserve the things that are dear to us. Sometimes Jesus comes in like a calamitous whirlwind and turns over the temples in our lives, doesn’t he? We encounter suffering and pain. We have to walk through seasons where we have no idea where he’s taking us.
And there’s one of two ways that we can respond to this. We can say, “Jesus, I’m done with this. You have no authority over me, and I’m not going to follow you if this is what following you looks like.” Or we, like his disciples, without knowing all the answers, without having any kind of clue where we’re being led, can learn to trust him, believing that Jesus is acting out of zeal for the purity of God’s dwelling place, for our purity, our cleansing.
The Temple of God (John 2:18–22)
You see, the problem is the Jews. In verse 18, “the Jews” becomes a common phrase (not always, but commonly) used in the Gospel of John for the enemies of Jesus from among his own people. Jesus was a Jew, but the enemies of Jesus come to him, and they have that first attitude: I’m not going to submit to or obey your authority. And they demand from him, “What sign do you show us for doing these things?” Now, the problem is, if they missed what just happened, they’ve already missed the sign. Jesus just performed the sign. Jesus acted it out in their midst. Jesus came purifying the temple as the fulfillment of Malachi 3 and Psalm 69 and of the Passover feast. Jesus has already performed the sign, but they still say, show us a sign to authenticate that you have the authority to do this.
At first it sounds like this might be honest intellectual curiosity. They just want to know. They just have doubts that they want to talk about. And that may be the case; we don’t know quite yet. But as we read, it’ll become clear that that’s not what’s happening here. In fact, what the enemies of Jesus are doing here is trying to put Jesus in a no-win situation. See, Jesus, you have one of two options here. Either you’re going to say, “Well, I’m not going to perform that sign,” which gives us an out, so that we can say, “Well, this guy is clearly a crackpot. We don’t have to listen to him.” And we can move on with our lives, business as usual. Even though, as one commentator said, what they really needed to do here was to repent from their sin and thank Jesus for the calamity that he had brought. That’s one option: either Jesus would fail to cough up a sign, or Jesus would say, “Well, okay, what sign would do it for you? What would meet your expectations?” But if he does that, then notice that Jesus is remaining under their authority. They’re telling Jesus to jump, and Jesus is saying, “Okay, well, how high do you need me to go here?” And they still retain the power. They’re not understanding that the Lord has suddenly come into his temple. They’re not understanding that Jesus is beginning his process of purification, that Jesus will, by his zeal, his holy jealousy, bring about all that he has come to do. And they want an excuse to reject it.
So Jesus, like he does in all of his interactions with his enemies when they try to put him in a jam, blows apart what they’re trying to do. And Jesus says, okay, I’m going to give you a sign, but it’s not really what you’re looking for, and you’re not going to like it. And in verse 19, Jesus gives us not a sign but the thing signified, what the sign of cleansing the temple pointed toward. He says in verse 19, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.” Now the Jews, Jesus’ enemies, say, it’s taken forty-six years to build this temple, and you’re going to raise it up in three days? They don’t believe him. This is what they were looking for. Jesus refuses to jump high enough to suit our standards; we can write him off as a crackpot and go on our merry way. Nobody could build a temple in three days.
But what they fail to understand is that Jesus is using what the rabbis called a māšāl. It’s a riddle, a saying that’s posed, that’s designed to get you to think a little bit deeper about what Jesus is saying. Well, of course Jesus isn’t going to rebuild, brick by brick, in three days, a temple that took forty-six years to build. That’s not what he’s talking about. John tells us that he said this about the temple of his body. Now, no one understands this at the time, not even his disciples. We read in verse 22 that it took until after Jesus was actually raised from the dead for his disciples to remember that he had said this, and then “they believed the Scripture and the word that Jesus had spoken.”
So Jesus says these words, offering them a riddle— and John lets us in on the secret at this point in the Gospel, because he wants us to know this is the purpose for which Jesus came. This is the reason he’s here. The cleansing of the temple, that was just a sign. But what it all points to, what all of the Old Testament shadows and prophecies and laws, and all of the proclamations of even someone like John the Baptist, what all of this has been leading up to, is the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ: that Jesus Christ, through his holy zeal, his jealousy, his burning, passionate desire that will stop at nothing to make sure that this mission is brought to completion, Jesus, by his zeal, will purify his temple. First through the destruction and then the glorification of his own body, and then by calling an extended temple: us, his church, his people.
We are called to be a part of the temple of God. You are the temple of God, is what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 3. Don’t you know that? Don’t you know that God’s Spirit dwells in you? Don’t you know, then, that Jesus will bring this calamity of purification and cleansing to your life, not because he wants to hurt you, not because he wants you to suffer and likes that, but because Jesus loves you too much to let you go, to let you continue on your own path? His love is too great to let you remain in the broken place that you are. Out of your brokenness, out of your ashes, Jesus wants to raise up someone who will be raised up in his resurrection glory. Jesus wants all that for you, so that you can live with him and his Father in the new heavens and the new earth forever and ever and ever.
But it’s going to take purification, because the cross, the way of the cross, the thing signified, what everything is pointing toward, is not just something that Jesus has to walk. Now, none of us are called to be nailed to a cross. I mean, some believers in the past have been, as a part of their martyrdom. But in our union with Jesus through faith (we’re united to him in our baptism, we’re united to him in our faith), and through our union with the death of Jesus, we die with him, which means that we can no longer present our bodies and our lives and our wills and our minds and our energies to the things that we formerly did. Instead, Jesus calls us to walk the way of the cross, which leads us directly into suffering, directly into calamity, directly into pain: the process by which he purifies us.
Genuine vs. Fleeting Faith (John 2:23–25)
Now, just as there were two general ways to respond to the calamity of this cleansing that Jesus brings into the temple, there are two ways to respond when we find out that Jesus means for us to walk the way of the cross too. And that’s what Jesus talks about in this third section, the significance, what this means for us. In verses 23 through 25 we read, “Now when he was in Jerusalem at the Passover Feast, many believed in his name when they saw the signs that he was doing.” Now stop there. That sounds like excellent news. The ministry of Jesus is off to a good start. He’s already getting around him a band of merry men. This is wonderful, right?
Not so fast. “But Jesus on his part did not entrust himself to them.” That verb there is the same as in “many believed in his name.” Jesus did not believe in them, is essentially what it says literally in verse 24, “because he knew all people and needed no one to bear witness about man, for he himself knew what was in man.” Jesus, in other words, recognizes that not all of these disciples are true disciples. Not all of these disciples are going to make it. Some of these disciples look upon Jesus and say, “Wow, a revolutionary! Wow, the long-awaited Messiah who’s going to kick the Romans out of our land! Wow, the long-awaited Messiah who’s going to clean up Israel from all the scum that’s been plaguing us! Wow!” And fill in the blanks with what they expected from Jesus to be useful for them.
But when the rubber hits the road, when things get difficult, when Jesus starts talking about the way of the cross for them (this especially comes to a head in John 6, when Jesus says, unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood, you have no life in you; you have no part of me), when Jesus starts saying those things, all of these thousands of people who have begun to follow him (this follows right after Jesus’ feeding of the five thousand), these thousands of people, begin to walk away. They’re in it for the perks. They’re in it to be riding the wave. They’re in it because they want to be on the ground level of something special and exciting and world-shaking. And Jesus says, oh, it will be all that, but you don’t understand. We have to pass under the shadow of the cross. I’m going to go there for you. You don’t have to go there for yourself. But understand that to follow me means that I will conform your life to that image, so that I can also conform you to the glory of my resurrection. What I go through, you must go through too.
And when Jesus’ many disciples, true and false, start to hear this dangerous, frightening message, we read that many thousands turned around and never followed Jesus again. And in John 6, Jesus poses the question to his own disciples: You’ve heard all the stuff I’ve said. You’ve seen all the stuff that I’ve done. You’ve watched my signs. You know my intentions, even if you don’t understand them. Will you too fall away? Will you too turn back? And Peter says words that I’ve personally clung to many times in some of the dark moments of my own journey. In John 6:68, Peter responds, “Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life, and we have believed, and have come to know, that you are the Holy One of God.”
Some of you are in the middle of this calamity. You don’t know why it’s there. You don’t know why it’s lasted as long as it has. You don’t know where the light at the end of the tunnel is. You just see Jesus turning over table after table after table in your life, and you don’t know why. Jesus isn’t going to come out and tell you, “Well, it’s because of this, that, and the other.” He tells you instead: Understand, this is the purpose for which I came, to make this broken world new, to make this broken world whole. And it’s going to require pain. Understand, I have come so that you don’t have to endure the worst of it, because if you went through the cross on your own, by yourself, you wouldn’t come out the other side. You’re not innocent. You deserve to undergo that for yourself. I will walk that path alone. All of you will abandon me, but I will go there for you, to purify you and to cleanse you. But understand that to follow me is more than a bandwagon kind of thing. I’m calling you to follow me not only in good times but in bad, not only when things are working well, it seems, but through the places of suffering, through the valley of the shadow of death.
This isn’t an easy thing, and there are times when you wonder, why am I doing this? But the question you have to come back to, the same question that the disciples, the true disciples, had to come back to in John 6, is this: Do you believe that Jesus is who he says he is? Do you believe that Jesus actually is the one who’s gathering up everything promised in the Old Covenant to fulfill it, to bring it to completion, and to offer it as a gift to all those who believe? Or is he just a fun guy to be around for a little while, until it’s inconvenient to keep going?
Brothers and sisters, let me plead with you: press on. Press on, not from your strength. You don’t have to walk out of here with answers to every one of your questions about the suffering you’re undergoing. But if Jesus is worth it, if Jesus is who he says he is, if Jesus is making all things new, if Jesus is the one who alone has passed under the cross so that you could go free, press on. Where else would you go? Who else has died for you? Who else brings you through suffering for your good and promises that nothing will be put to waste?
Get next week's study by email
Mondays: the study, the PDF and the sermon.